I was nervous seeing Fun Home last night on Broadway for the first time after seeing it several times as the Newman, kind of like having lunch with a college sweetheart 10 years later. But I loved it even more, with a few quibbles.
I think that the staging in the round definitely heightened and improved some aspects of the production, and Sam Gold did an amazing job with an almost-impossible task. If something is in the round, it's just logical to assume that you're going to be looking at actors' backs for part of the time. There's no way around it. That's why some aspects were better downtown, in my humble opinion.
***********POSSIBLE SPOILERS**************
Improved on Broadway:
Welcome to Our House on Maple Avenue in the round establishes the house as a character in its own right, with the characters as its indentured servants, a theme continued throughout the show. (As other posters have noted.) The actors use the entire stage very well as they tidy up in increasing panic.
Come to the Fun Home was effective and fun in the round, with new choreography contributing greatly. Only one coffin, though, not two.
In the category of flat-out awesome, the staging for Raincoat of Love was very different from downtown and really worked. Several characters rise out of the middle of the stage while mist floods the entire area. The lighting definitely contributed to an ethereal and dreamlike quality. Very effective and fun.
The big winner in the restaging is Days and Days (with a minor detail detracting). Having Judy Kuhn up and about as she sings really increased the poignancy of the song. At the end, she and Middle Alison exchange looks that are devastating. And as Helen exits the stage, Alison continues to look at her, conveying so many emotions on her face. I could see this clearly from the 400 section, but other sections might not.
The Edges of the World: I think this one benefited from being in the round. The set pieces had been retracted into the floor, but the huge holes remained. As Michael Cerveris made his way around the stage, you're worried that he's going to fall in to one of them. This was another case where sitting in the 400 section was good. You see him from the back during the climactic event.
Better downtown:
I think Ring of Keys suffered in the translation. From my seat in the 400 section, I think I saw the back of the actress's head about three-quarters of the time. I'm guessing it's better from the other sections. Nothing could compare to the simple staging at the Newman, with Small Alison standing in the center of the stage, singing the song so beautifully. A revelation.
The reveal of the house. Uptown, Gold got as close as he could. The furniture rises up from the floor all at once and the chandeliers lower. The effect is enhanced by Joan's reaction of awe. But it's hard to compete downtown with the back wall of the Newman covered for the first time with the wallpaper that we had gotten a glimpse of in Bruce's hand earlier.
Neither better nor worse:
Changing My Major seemed about as effective as downtown.
Telephone Wire, which is I think my favorite song in the show, had some good aspects and some detriments. The staging is ingenious, with Alison and Bruce seated in the middle of the stage on an elevated platform that slowly revolves. You are seeing the backs of heads for part of the time, but your view is continually changing. I still prefer the staging at the Newman.
*********END SPOILERS*********
I was happy that the audience seemed really into the show and was very responsive. Some jokes got a bigger laugh than I remember from downtown. The performances across the board are wonderful. I look forward to seeing this again at some point! If anyone is on the fence about this show, just do it and go!
Updated On: 4/5/15 at 10:56 AM