Got around to seeing this last night and while I'm happy some of you enjoyed the show, I spent much of my time watching in a state of complete shock.
Wow. Just wow.
If you went and enjoyed it, I'm glad that was your experience. I wish it was my experience.
Parts of the show that were attempting to be funny played as uncomfortable stereotypes. I cringed watching the mitzvah at the top of the second act. During "Jersey," I thought the production owes the entire state of New Jersey an apology. If the song wasn't questionable, those license plates...Ugh.
Mr. Davenport came out at the top of the preview, celebrating how this show is unique because it's an original musical and proudly declaring how it's not The Iceman Cometh. I'd imagine Mr. O'Neill is thankful for that. He's right about original musicals being great. Problem is that just being an original musical does not make it great, or even good. While I don't believe every show has to be high art, I do believe a show should have some craft and be more than a vanity project for the creatives involved.
On the positives, performance wise, the cast really is giving everything they have. Brandon Williams really stood out as Tygen Billows. Thought he was excellent. Off topic but related, did anyone else think the Tygen Billows character was borrowed straight from the movie Dodgeball? Even though they seemingly went to the well too many times with the "My father used to say" gimmick, his performance was earnest and funny. The cowbell bit was cute and worked as a nice little surprise.
The show's rally cry or Mr. Davenport's rally cry seems to be if you don't like the show, you are a theater snob and don't like having fun. That's all well and good but the argument would be stronger if the show was good. While HOH may not always work, it's such a better crafted show. GTTBT's book feels like it has 13 writers. Oh wait...While I admire Mr. Davenport's energy and passion for the production, I simply wish more of that energy and passion was coming from the book and lyrics of the production.
Updated On: 7/30/18 at 12:06 PM