With no two-part structure to compare this to, I thought this was very good but not great. Four covers were on today, including Eric Cheung for Scorpius (a real standout) and Ted Deasy for Amos / Dumbledore.
From a production value standpoint, tonight was — for lack of a better word — magical. The special effects throughout make the entire show pop. I won't soon forget the Dementors effect at the end of Act I. It's no wonder this swept the play design categories at the Tonys when it was eligible.
Shoutout to John Tiffany's slick direction and Steven Hoggett's movement adding some fluidity to the proceedings. The various "wand dances" and the Death Eaters' march were highlights, set to some apt, moody underscoring by Imogen Heap.
It's been a long while since I finished reading through the Harry Potter books, and even though I knew much of the backstory, I still thought portions of Jack Thorne's libretto were quite choppy, specifically in the second half. Harry's name is in the title, but this clearly is the Albus and Scorpius show (with some decent support from Harry, Ron, Ginny, Hermione, and Draco). Cheung and Joel Meyers made quite the meal out of these deep characters.
Some visible audience reactions today to Dumbledore's first entrance, as well as the Dolores Umbridge and Bellatrix Lestrange reveals.
I'll also shout out Jane Bruce — she was an ensemble standout in Jagged Little Pill and she nailed Delphi's descent into evil here.
Tonight clocked in at a 3:26 runtime before curtain call (started at exactly 7 PM, ended 10:26), and I hadn't felt this comfortable in a seat in some time.
Six years into its NYC run, and Potter shows no signs of letting up on its charm.
“I am furious, but I am sailing.”
Updated On: 5/31/24 at 11:26 PM