It was actually pretty darned good with Carol Channing. She may not be the megastar that Midler is (as a result of her concert/TV/movie history), but on Broadway Channing is a legend.
When I saw the show in the early 90s with Carol, I guess it wasn't "necessary," but it's a super musical and was truly enjoyable from start to finish. And seeing Channing was pure joy.
I don't disagree though that Midler, because of her recognizability outside of the theater community, will be a huge draw. And her icon status will certainly generate a buzz in the nightly audiences. That's to be expected. In fact, it sounds like it even affords her the freedom to flub her lines on occasion and start and restart songs and still be met with sheer adoration by the audience by a simple turn to the audience and a "shut up." Not so sure Bernadette Peters could get away with that.
Midler's a rockstar. And as Dolly she is definitely an event. And the show sounds truly wonderful.
A great musical, with a dynamic personality at the helm. I can understand why it's getting the reviews it is.
CT2NYC said: "poisonivy2 said: "I don't think Hello Dolly! is strong enough of a musical to survive without an extremely charismatic Dolly Levi. The storyline and jokes were dated even in 1964. Therefore I don't mind that Bette Midler is doing the Divine Miss M schtick. I mean it's a very enjoyable musical but I don't think it's in the top tier of American musicals.
I agree with this completely. Before I saw the show this past Wednesday, I was only moderately familiar with HELLO, DOLLY! Other than the title song, my main exposure to it was from the movie WALL-E. My first impression was that I couldn't imagine seeing the show with anyone but a megastar like Bette Midler. Without her, this revival doesn't seem overly necessary, in my opinion. Also, a major part of why I enjoyed it so much was the contagious enthusiasm of the audience. I thought the rest of the cast was excellent, but they're not working with material that I consider on the same level as my favorite classic musicals. Having said that, I think the title number is exceptional, and I would pay to see it again. The dancing is also superb. On the whole, the show is so joyous that it provides a real antidote to the cynicism of the day, and that boundless exuberance just might be its greatest strength, in addition to Ms. Midler's performance.
"