chrishuyen said: "I was thinking a bit about the ending of the show, and while I can kind of see how they thought Why Don't You Love Me would be a good ending for Imelda's arc (with everyone having turned against her for the atrocities she's committed), I think the way it plays out feels more sympathetic than they probably intended. Like I heard someone walking out of the show saying they felt bad for her because she "tried her best". It feels like they need more of a villain song where it's obvious she's lost sense of morality in the face of her own selfishness or something.
I think this was the main problem for me. Some spoilers ahead.
The story really relies on the music, but the music doesn't give Imelda a true "heel turn" moment. By the time we get to "Why Don't You Love Me," the song feels abrupt and/or unearned.
Sure, she's cruel to her childhood friend and Aquino (in a moment that could ambiguously be seen as a moment of political mercy), but those scenes felt like cheap exposition given that it's the music that's supposed to move the show along.
I know it's not really fair to compare the two shows, but I kept thinking about Evita. Obviously, it depends entirely on how the show's directed, but the Act II songs in Evita build up to Eva's villainy, as you slowly start to revile her in Rainbow High/Rainbow Tour/Waltz for Che and Eva.
I didn't get that gradualism in Here Lies Love. Poor Me and Seven Years are songs that could make Imelda seem sympathetic, even though in the former (as the cheated-on wife), she's seizing power, and in the latter, she's exiling Aquino (as a power move thinly veiled as an act of political mercy).
The way Please Don't is directed makes her seem mildly sympathetic, especially to an audience that's really only half paying attention to the plot. My jaw dropped when 3/4ths of the floor crowd bopped along to Please Don't, which is a song where Imelda's trying to shore up her authoritarianism by casting herself as the victim.
So the songs don't really give me a reason to hate Imelda, which, by the time she's wailing "Why Don't You Love Me?," I find myself asking myself the same question. It didn't come off as a song where Imelda's trying to take stock of her downfall; it came off as Imelda being whiny. (This is not a knock on Arielle Jacobs, who sang it well -- this is more a comment on the direction and the tone of the song itself.)
Sure, Riots & Bombs and Order 1081 try to paint the horrors of the Marcos regime. But being told that Imelda is a terrible person who, with her husband, did terrible things, and seeing it for ourselves, are two different things.
(EDIT: Also, the joke's ultimately on me, as I'm going to see this again after it opens -- mostly in the spirit of second chances, and to see what they change. So they're getting my money either way.)
Updated On: 7/8/23 at 05:07 PM