"Hedwig (I was waiting for JCM), On the Town (I haven't really been grabbed by any of the promotional materials), Honeymoon in Vegas (the mixed word of mouth put me off), and If/Then."
Do the Hedwig lottery again and again and again until you get in, it is worth missing the other three shows entirely to catch Hedwig once.

Although, given the schedules, the others do have shows when Hedwig doesn't, so I suppose you can try them on Hedwig's off days.
I do love If/Then, though. The songs are great. Idina is at the top of her game. I plan to see this twice before it closes yet (well, once... I'm already booked for the final show).
I'm seeing On the Town tonight, so I'm interested to finally see it. I was supposed to see it in November, but then my family was debating a Thanksgiving gathering that never materialized, but I flipped some of my mid-November shows to early 2015 just in case, including OTT.
"I want to know what shows he's working on..."
What sane person involved in three Broadway-bound shows would out themselves like that?! And who assumes anyone successful is a man?
"THEN they found out that Ben Brantley (who gave "Honeymoon" a glowing review at Paper Mill a year and a half ago) was going to be out-of-town until the beginning of January."
Whoa, what a gamble... and one that ultimately didn't pay off. I mean, sure, they got the good review, but no one seems to care. I didn't hate the show by any means, but it is ultimately a very strange show and definitely hard to market.
"I kinda find it fascinating how people are so turned off by this show, but yet Book of Mormon is a smash hit"
What's the connective tissue here?! BOM is known for pushing the edge with its content, especially with regards to religion, etc. HIV is meant to be a fun romp, but people are pushed away by some of the story's inherent misogyny, among other issues.
Honestly, I think HIV is getting a bit of a pass because it was a movie. If someone brought this to stage as an original concept, it would be picked apart a lot more. Take my girlfriend away for the weekend? Flying Elvises? What exactly is this show?! I mean, I had issues with the book to The Last Ship, but since this is a known property, you sort of have to accept the known quantities here in a way you don't with original works.
Not that anyone was clamoring for HIV...
Updated On: 2/3/15 at 03:09 AM