I was at the preview this evening and thought it was a solid evening; a good time that falls short of ever being truly riveting or hilarious. The whole evening kind of simmers and percolates, but never kicks into a roiling boil.
I like the idea of this being set on an alternate Earth. It immediately took me to all the Harry Wellses on The Flash. This was like Hillary and Bill from Earth 38. I wish Hnath had played around a little more with the differences between Earth 1 Hillary and Earth 38 Hillary. Part of the fun of Tom Cavanagh getting to play a new Harry each season is seeing the new spin he’ll put on the same essence of Wells. Despite this being an alternate world, this is pretty much Hillary as we know her.
Despite being an intermissionless 90 minutes, there is an act one and two, and I was so hoping act two would transport to another Earth to replay the scene (or continue the scene) with different results.
The cast is great. Both Metcalf and Lithgow are wonderful.
Gary and Hillary and Clinton are good companion pieces. They are both extremely well-acted, often fun, thoughtful and smart, but each is still slightly unrefined, holding us back from experiencing its true potential.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!