Posted: 5/12/24 at 11:26pm
I saw this tonight and loved it. I've never seen the movie so I was asking my friend at intermission what differs, etc. But I was really into it. I agree, though, I think the opening number is stupid. I think waiting until the actual reveals makes more sense because the audience is waiting for the Michelle Williams / Potion entrance, so it just builds excitement. If you give her to us right away then it's kind of a "meh" because we've already met her. I think open with "For the Gaze" and then cushion her song/scene out a bit. I didn't like the song they gave her at her house. So that needs some working.
And honestly, the momentum of Act 1 was so much fun, I think they could just make this a tight 90 min and call it a day. We don't need Chris' second act number, and there's a lot of filler with dancing and stuff that we just don't really need. I hate this notion in modern musicals that every major character needs a song of their own. They don't.
The ladies were fabulous. I would go back tomorrow to watch them again. Hilty's number at the Valet was Tony worthy to me. Just insanely hilarious, well acted, well sung, brilliant. Simard was just as equally brilliant. Her bit with "come" to Sieber had me dying.
I think the show works and the audience I was with was eating it up. And it seems to be selling pretty decently. I think they've got a major hit if they can retool some things. I think making Williams more of a cameo would be smarter. Easier to stunt cast, etc. And I don't think she understood the humor of the Act 2 opening song where she just kept popping up in random places. There was no humor in her eyes like she was in on the joke.
Also I wanted a bit more physical comedy. I mean the ladies are shooting each other and hitting each other with shovels but it all felt so phony. I want to see more physical comedy.
