I just got home, and while I have some qualms, I have to say that I'm on cloud 9 and bursting with toe-tapping melodies. JRB has done it again, but this time in a Cy Coleman mold; coming off the heels of his ravishing score for Bridges, this effort is all the more impressive.
First though, it must be noted they actually decided to ADAPT the film for the stage rather than just cut and paste song into the film script. This is basically the anti-Rocky approach. That musical tried so hard to throw in any line of dialogue, scene or bit of imagery from the film in an attempt to create a thrill akin to finding Waldo when they spotted a reference. Honeymoon in Vegas is just the opposite. The general story is there, but almost no dialogue is lifted from the film, all the gags- funny or otherwise- have been newly created, and most importantly, all the ick and misogyny (a major problem in the film) have been jettisoned by some smart book changes.
SJP is almost like a battered wife in the movie. The way she's traded about and denied any agency. You never feel she has a chance to fall in love with Caan, and who would want to anyway? He's a disgusting pig.
Danza is suave and stylish. He's a smooth operator, but there's also something genuine and melancholy underneath his slick exterior. I guess this is SPOILER since it's different from the film, so...
*****
Betsy is the one who proposes that she and Tommy impulsively rush back to Vegas to get married instead of Tommy basically forcing her into marriage by threat of physical abuse. Tommy is manipulative, but much less so than in the film. Betsy honestly starts to fall for him, or at least be charmed by him as she offered such a nice alternative, even if it's momentary. He's really her moment in the woods- she has an and then it's back to or and DOES make the or mean more than it did before!
*****
Danza isn't the greatest singer, but JRB is smartly tailored all the songs to show him in the best light. He gets some jazzy, very City of Angels type numbers, plus a real showstopper in act two.
I liked Rob McClure more than I've liked him before. He's funny and fresh. Brynn O'Malley was rather stifled in the Annie revival, but she gets to let loose here and I was impressed. She's got some Laura Benanti qualities, and had the setting not been moved to the present I'm sure she would have unintentional evoked The Wedding Singer.
While the book does fix the misogyny aspect, it is sometimes light on the laughs/finds a chuckle instead of a belly laugh. The show is always pleasant, but the hearty laughs come in fits and spurts.
The score is the true star and yes they are selling the OBCR in the theater already; no iTunes for me! This is going right on the shelf between High Spirits and House of Flowers!
One thing I hate is generic lyrics and JRB always impresses me with his character and/or situation specific lyrics.
The only song I was left wanting for was a Dirty Rotten Scoundrels number for Rob and Tony.
The set is a little sparse and sadly projections are often used in favor of actual physical pieces, but at least you can rationalize that it is Vegas (and Hawaii), and these places are both overrun with tacky tourists and especially Vegas has a trashy, chintzy side to it.
The orchestra is a delight.
Of the five Broadway musical offerings so far this season, this is by far my favorite.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!