Posted: 2/2/19 at 4:22pm
qolbinau said: "The show is closing early now, I thought I'd revisit and it was AMAZING, even more so than I remember it being at the Hampstead. Is this the most complex musical ever written? Of course I never saw Tonya, but I really think Sharon is giving one of those rare iconic performances like Alice Ripley in N2N, Ebersole in Grey Gardensetc.
I almost broke down when she sung these lyrics (copied/pasted from online so can't vouch for accuracy):
Murder me God down in that basement,
murder my dreams so I stop wantin,
murder my hope of him returnin,
strangle the pride that make me crazy!
Make me forget so I stop grievin.
Scour my skin till I stop feelin.
Take Caroline away cause I cain't be her,
take her away I cain't afford her.
Tear out my heart
Strangle my soul
"
I love how the refrain from "I Hate the Bus" plays here too. It's one of the most brilliant moments (amongst so many!) in the musical: a tender and sad moment when Caroline rejects hope and asks God to turn her to salt. But those notes from "I Hate the Bus" remind us that she was Emmie 20ish years ago. She must move past her dreams and provide for her family.
It's too bad to hear that this current production isn't a hit in the UK. I'm envious you were able to catch Sharon's performance! I was hopeful that it would make a transfer to New York.
I saw this on Broadway in college, and it remains an incredibly cherished theatrical memory. While I didn't grow up poor and black in the South, it still resonated with me as a child of immigrants. I would love to revisit it again, especially in the current political environment.