Posted: 10/16/25 at 8:53pm
joevitus said: "
Famed record producer Goddard Lieberson never liked dialogue on his cast albums. I mostly agree, but I think it's rather nifty how Shepard gave us an encapsulation of the play on his Spider Woman. And, of course, I think the difference between the days when people owned albums with a synopsis included, vs. today when people mostly download music with nothing else to go by than the numbers makes a difference in how the material should bepresented (to be clear, he recorded Spidar Woman in the CD era,before downloads existed much of anywhere besides Napster)."
Have you read Shepard's book? (I know way back in this thread I already quoted much of what he said about making the replacement cast Spider Woman recording.) It's interesting that Lieberson was his mentor in how to make cast albums, but he discusses their different views about dialogue--Shepard suggests had Lieberson made the Company original cast album he probably would have left out all the dialogue between verses in The Little Things You Do Together (which IMHO would have been a great loss, although Shepard did have them slightly re-write the dialogue.) Of course then in the 80s, having the luxury of CDs with more time than a single vinyl disc would give you helped with this too. (I do have a friend who played the Spider Woman original cast album some months back for the first time, and she said she got no sense of the story. Of course she easily could have followed along with Wiki, but...)
