RippedMan said: "I mean, in a way it's kind of smart. It seems like a show that would appeal to the NYC theater goers and not tourists. And there aren't really the same amount of tourists right now, so a show centered at the nyc theater goer might be a smart sell."
Unfortunately, this logic hasn't proven to hold up. This was exactly the same thing everyone thought going into Fall '21, but all of "aimed at locals" shows still failed, and the traditionally tourist-driven shows still did well.
The Times article with the leaked grosses touched on this topic:
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/31/theater/broadway-hamilton-wicked-lion-king.html
Also, I would question what we think of as "aimed at locals." Kimberly Akimbo already had an NYC run, so most of the local theatre-goers already had the chance to see it. It sold well, but wasn't a crazy hot ticket, which indicates that the demand didn't reach far beyond the supply. And the supply is about to get a lot bigger.
Granted, not all local Broadway-goers pay attention to Off-Broadway, so with the right marketing they could certainly increase their reach to locals, to a certain extent. But I question whether it will be enough.
I also agree with some of the sentiments expressed about the show's emotional weight: it seems to me that the show was too light and feel-good to land an emotional punch, but was too small and quirky to tap into the "feel good" tourist audience.
But even if I didn't personally love the show, I do hope it succeeds! I'm definitely not wishing failure on it by any means.
Updated On: 2/25/22 at 03:24 PM