Just got back from tonight's show and I have to report that it was sadly the least captivating (my poor attempt to find a PC way of saying "the worst") performance of the show that I've been to now six times.
Taye is still messing up lines. He plays it off very to those unfamiliar with the show, but as somebody who knows JCM's brilliant book quite well, I cringed multiple times when he mangled some of the script's perfect phrasings.
To give Taye a little bit of credit, the show got out around 9:50 tonight, about a half hour shorter than the performance I went to very early in his run. He's also settling into the physicality a bit better (by which I mean that tonight, he sweated 1 gallon as opposed to 2 gallons the first time); however, I thought he was going to collapse backwards into the stage when he was emerging from the "Wig in a Box" quick-change.
For me, something happened in the middle of his Tommy Gnosis monologue, and he just completely lost any sense of a spark he had going throughout his performance. The typically heartrending and profound "Wicked Little Town" reprise just felt like a dude singing a song. I normally never want "Midnight Radio" to end, but tonight, I couldn't wait for Yitzhak to emerge and close the song.
I think the following moment best encapsulates the show I saw tonight: when the green spotlight hit Taye at the beginning of "Hedwig's Lament," the expression that he made prompted half of the audience laugh out loud.
So disappointed. Will definitely not be returning to the Belasco any time before mid-October.
Updated On: 8/4/15 at 10:32 PM