Posted: 7/3/20 at 2:56pm
Broadway61004 said: "CT2NYC said: "Broadway61004 said: "Georgeanddot2 said: "Saving this one to watch with my family for the 4th of July tomorrow.
Just a heads up, this is currently Oscar eligible. Unless the Oscars make a special ruling rendering this ineligible, I think this could be a Best Picture contender. We could see some of the performances recognized as well."
It may technically still be eligible right now, but I'd say there's less than a 1% chance it ends up that way. Otherwise every single Met production shown in cinemas over the past 10 years would have been eligible.
And even if it does end up eligible by some miracle, I'd say there's less than a 1% chance it would get nominated. Oscar voters are already completely rebelling against streaming services, so something on a streaming service that isn't even a film in the traditional sense? No way.
I could, however, see the Academy giving Lin an honorary Oscar or something along those lines."
1. In 1975, James Whitmore received a Best Actor nomination for his filmed stage performance in GIVE ‘EM HELL, HARRY, so there is precedent.
2. Due to the pandemic, streaming films will be eligible this year without a theatrical release.
3. In 2019, Roma, a Netflix film, won 3 Oscars: Best International Feature, Best Cinematography, and Best Director.
No miracle necessary,there’s everyreason to believeHamiltonwill compete at the Oscars, as well as at the Golden Globes, where I think a Best Picture Musical or Comedy win is already a good bet, even withWest Side Storyyet to come."
1. Yes, I never said there wasn't any precedent, but that was one award 45 years ago. To think that has any bearing on now is not accurate.
2. They have said that films streaming are eligible, but they have not defined what a film is. This is not a film. This is a video recording of a staged event. Do you really expect every stand-up special that premieres on Netflix is going to be eligible for Best Picture?
3. Roma is exactly what I'm referring to. One of the most acclaimed films of the year lost Best Picture to Green Book because, by several voters' own admission, they wouldn't vote for something that they felt wasn't a true film.
So no, Hamilton will not be eligible or win until they actually make a film adaptation of it down the road."
Roma WAS a true film...it just wasn't shown in many movie houses.
Personally,
I think it makes more sense as a possible Emmy contender because, in the end, it really is not a movie...it is a taped version of a great show. The Emmy's already have many categories in which taped shows appear, and are not considered anything other than the norm.
I see it tonight, and am excited about the initial reactions here; I doubt it will change my mind re Emmy vs. Oscar. I also agree that it should be eligible when and if an 'opened-up' film is made, with shots of the Battle of Yorktown, and with Hamilton walking around Manhattan, and the duel is filmed out of doors, etc., etc., etc. That is the movie I really want to see, whereas this is the (apparently extremely well done)taped version of a great stage show that I really want to see also. Tonight). I fear, probably unnecessarily so, that if this did manage to get Oscar nominations, (a)it still would not win them...well maybe Daveed Diggs, but could hinder the real movie from getting made.