I guess I'm a newbie... I first saw the show in March on a whim. I was supposed to be seeing Brooklyn - talk about good fortune!!!!
It was immediate, though. I fell head over heels with it's spirit, and passion, and irreverency, and... well, I guess you all know.

I had heard so much about the show, and when I finally got the opportunity to see it, I guess I just didn't know what to think. I mean, when I was 9, I had family friends who went into NYC all the time and just kept seeing Rent over and over, so I knew it must have something to it... didn't know it was gonna be like it is today, though. I consider myself a true Renthead. As soon as I see a show, it becomes my life. I can honestly say I knew almost every word to the OBCR in about two weeks.
People who are introduced to movie versions of shows first usually get bad raps and are considered posers and whatnot by people who've experienced the show first, but I really don't think that's fair. And I know what I'm talking about, because I saw the Phantom movie before I saw the Broadway show, and that's one of my favorite shows of all time, as well.
I guess what I'm trying to say is this - it's art. It's for everyone. It doesn't matter what version you saw first. As long as you love it.