IN TRANSIT looks like regional artwork to me, not Broadway quality. On the other hand though, A BRONX TALE's paper mill artwork was much better looking than the Broadway version...
The Present isn't terrible but it's not great either. I think it's the way Cate Blanchett's body is positioned + the dress but it looks photoshopped to make her arms and body smaller and slimmer. When did people used to take Playbill photos for older plays? I like those older Playbills that look like a scene from the play. Or, barring that, just a good photo like The Apple Tree. I often find myself thinking "this can't be the best photo you took."
The background looks like wood but something about the font and color scheme of Come From Away keeps making me think the show has something to do with the beach or being underwater.
The Price is a solid design. At least there's an idea there.