It was OK, but needs some work.
I kept noticing anachronisms that stuck out. Small things that aren’t a big deal to the plot (Babe Ruth was not a famous name in 1913, “Black” wasn’t the term used for people in the 1910s), but since this show is basically a sung Wikipedia article, inaccuracies in one place made me side-eye how well-researched and accurate the whole thing is.
I really did not like the set. It’s so bare and empty with
huge wooded doors that slide on and off-stage. There is so much space that goes unused, these massive doors just tower above everyone.
The choice to have women play male characters didn’t really work for me, as all I could picture was that dreadful 1776 revival.
I liked the music, and the actresses harmonizing together sounded amazing. I didn’t realize this was almost a sung-through show. The first act could definitely be tightened up a bit.
Because it was the first preview I can’t really judge the audience response, since it was the typical over-excited and enthusiastic crowd. Great energy but annoying how they kept clapping and cheering over people’s lines.
"It's Phantom meets Hamlet... Phamlet!"