I actually have three daughters that happen to be the exact same ages as yours. I see pretty much everything in New York, both Broadway and off Broadway, so I think I am a good person to offer you an opinion. My two older girls are pretty mature for their ages.
School of Rock for all 3 of your girls. All of my girls would love it, including my 4 year old.
On Your Feet for all 3 of your girls. Lots of fun, lots of dancing.
My 11 and 13 year olds would absolutely LOVE Dear Evan Hansen. There are a couple mild sexual references and some serious themes, so you would have to decide if it is right for your family through the lense of your particular parenting style. But if I could take my two tween daughters to any two shows on Broadway right now it would definitely be Hamilton and DEH.
As a dark horse ... if Ride The Cyclone extends into January (and I have been told there is a good chance it will) that may be another good choice for your two older girls, but not your 4 year old.
And if you go to something like DEH or Cyclone with your older girls, maybe send dad with the little one to Lion King .... my four year olds favorite musical.
Updated On: 11/20/16 at 02:49 AM