I like Borle, but that second Tony win felt like a fluke of a weak year. He doesn't work terribly often, but has shown his breadth as an actor, has found success in comedic and dramatic parts, and can sometimes elevate material (Starcatcher). Give me Borle over Gavin Creel or Andy Karl or Rob McClure any day.
Shaiman & Wittman must also like him, since he was in Smash, Wonka, and now this.