Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, My Least Favorite Audrey Ever

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, My Least Favorite Audrey Ever

I've seen just about every Audrey in this current production, and while there's been things I've loved, liked and disliked about each of them, I was the most disappointed in Betsy Wolfe. Especially after enjoying her in & Juliet, Drood and other random performances.

She plays the part as if she's got no clue about the energy of Little Shop, the comedy and the camp and instead is presenting it as a 101 level dramatic role that just sucked the life and energy out of all of her scenes.

Ethan and everyone else in the company was in a much better show than she was, and you could tell how much more fun they were having to.

Did I see an off night or is this just miscasting / odd direction / a misfire?

Any rumors on who is next?

Updated On: 9/2/26 at 09:27 AM

#2

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

I haven't seen it but I was under the impression the Audrey direction in this production was intended to present her as a fully serious dramatic role. The clips I've seen of other people all seemed to be an Audrey that's more bogged down by her trauma than the original.

I try not to be that person who's like "the original is always the best!!" but Ellen Greene is just as important to Audrey's creation as Ashman & Menken. Everything she does is perfect and feels embedded in the character.

#3

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

Let me tell you, her Everyday Rapture colleague wasn’t good in it either. The role itself is not very large and it’s not worth seeing again even for a great performer. Time to retire this show and leave it in community theaters and schools where it belongs.

#4

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

I thought Ethan and Betsy were both fine. I went in with high expectations and they did not exceed them. It felt like the comedy was lacking or miscalibrated at times and it sort of left me cold at the end. This is a show that really benefits from being molded to its comedic ensemble, and I understand there’s been a revolving door or understudies and replacements lately, which makes it tough to form a cohesive unit.

But I was similarly not blown away by the show when I saw this production’s original duo, so it might be more of a Michael Mayer problem for me.

Updated On: 9/1/26 at 09:58 AM

#5

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

I saw the show this past Thursday and have to agree about Betsy. I've seen many versions of the show over the years, and have worked on three productions. I felt no emotion in her Audrey. However she does have a great voice when belting out Audrey's big numbers.

I loved Ethan and the three urchins. They were perfect.

#6

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

I wish I could have seen more Audrey's! I was struck by Tammy Blanchard's naturalistic, even nihilistic, performance. It took a moment to adjust but I found it was especially well off-set by Jeremy Jordan's classic, and terrific, musical comedy performance. I thought Blanchard's performance retained the humor and the sweetness while transforming the abuse into something genuinely tragic. It felt like she planted the seeds of her end during Somewhere That's Green... an Audrey who knew it was all just a fantasy... and then when she realizes she's dying I saw genuine comfort in her Audrey. All that said... it's not what I was expecting (and admittedly a stronger voice wouldn't have hurt) but I have grown to think it was a really stunning accomplishment.

I can't tell if these complaints about Wolfe are a disagreement with the choice of the production or a genuinely bad performance. Both possibilities sound possible and I wish I could see for myself.

I'm so glad everyone is sharing so I can take in the conversation.


Jesus saves. I spend.
#7

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

Ke3 said: "I haven't seen it but I was under the impression the Audrey direction in this production was intended to present her as a fully serious dramatic role. The clips I've seen of other people all seemed to be an Audrey that's more bogged down by her trauma than the original.

I try not to be that person who's like "the original is always the best!!" but Ellen Greene is just as important to Audrey's creation as Ashman & Menken. Everything she does is perfect and feels embedded in the character.
"

I haven’t seen the production since the original cast, but I wouldn’t really call Tammy Blanchard’s take on Audrey as “fully serious.” She played Audrey like she was addicted to tranquilizers. It was a very strange performance. I don’t know if subsequent performers have gone that extreme of a route.

What makes Greene definitive and never yet surpassed is that everything was played very straight and very deeply felt. And that’s what made her Audrey both so lovable and so funny. She had tacky taste but thought it was glamorous. Her dreams were so modest but she treated them like she wanted the moon. That’s both the tragedy and comedy of Audrey. I have yet to see another performer who really got it the same way, or allowed themselves to for fear of copying Greene.


"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
#8

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

Kad said: "Ke3 said: "I haven't seen it but I was under the impression the Audrey direction in this production was intended to present her as a fully serious dramatic role. The clips I've seen of other people all seemed to be an Audrey that's more bogged down by her trauma than the original.

I try not to be that person who's like "the original is always the best!!" but Ellen Greene is just as important to Audrey's creation as Ashman & Menken. Everything she does is perfect and feels embedded in the character.
"

I haven’t seen the production since the original cast, but I wouldn’t really call Tammy Blanchard’s take on Audrey as “fully serious.” She played Audrey like she was addicted to tranquilizers. It was a verystrange performance. I don’t know if subsequent performers have gone that extreme of a route.

What makes Greene definitive and never yet surpassed is thateverything was played very straight and very deeply felt. And that’s what made her Audrey both so lovable and so funny. She had tacky taste but thought it was glamorous. Her dreams were so modest but she treated them like she wanted the moon. That’s both the tragedy and comedy of Audrey. I have yet to see another performer who really got it the same way, or allowed themselves to for fear of copying Greene.


I forget her name, but whoever played opposite Jake Gyllenhaal had that same effect.

#10

Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

theblackumbrella said: "Kad said: What makes Greene definitive and never yet surpassed is thateverything was played very straight and very deeply felt. And that’s what made her Audrey both so lovable and so funny. She had tacky taste but thought it was glamorous. Her dreams were so modest but she treated them like she wanted the moon. That’s both the tragedy and comedy of Audrey. I have yet to see another performer who really got it the same way, or allowed themselves to for fear of copying Greene.

I forget her name, but whoever played opposite Jake Gyllenhaal had that same effect.
"



You don't say. 🤣

#11

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

Yes, Jake's Audrey was Ellen Greene.

I thought Betsy was quite good when I went during her first week, it was certainly a more subdued take but it worked for me. Nikki M. James was similarly sad, often at the expense of humor but it was heartbreaking to me.

I think the production is pretty pitch perfect from start to finish and have revisited to see a number of the casts over the years. I think Ethan is exceptional.
#13

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

Kerry Butler was bad as Audrey for the same reasons she bad as Meredith in Bat Boy. She’s supposed to be soft spoken housewife in an unhappy marriage and she’s playing it like a woman on the verge of a nervous breakdown which is why she was so fabulous in Mean Girls and Heathers.

#14

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

Betsy and Ethan are really good in their roles, but not great. And the fact that they scheduled absences for half of August and will be gone so much of September is so strange. Why cast people that are so often out of town?

#15

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

“Little Shop of Horrors satirizes many things: science fiction, ‘B’ movies, musical comedy itself, and the the Faust legend. There will, therefore, be a temptation to play it for camp and low-comedy. This is a great and potentially fatal mistake. The script keeps its tongue firmly in cheek, so the actors should not. Instead, they should play with simplicity, honesty, and sweetness--even when events are at their most outlandish. The show’s individual “style” will evolve naturally from the words themselves and an approach to acting and singing them that is almost child-like in its sincerity and intensity. By way of example, Audrey poses like Fay Wray from time to time. But she does this because she’s in genuine fear and happens to see the world as her private ‘B’ movie--not because she’s “commenting” to the audience on the the silliness of her situation. Having directed the original New York production of Little Shop myself, and subsequently having seen it in many versions and even many languages, I can vouch for the fact that when Little Shop is at its most honest, it is also at its funniest and most enjoyable.”

- Howard Ashman
#16

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

Fred Mason said: "Kerry Butler was bad as Audrey for the same reasons she bad as Meredith in Bat Boy. She’s supposed to be soft spoken housewife in an unhappy marriage and she’s playing it like a womanon the verge of a nervous breakdown which is why she was so fabulous in Mean Girls and Heathers."

Not sure I agree with how she plays it. But she'd NOT GOOD as Meredith. They went for the "look she's an alum of the original" - and now all grown up. No one cares THAT much. They should have cast a fierce woman with real fire who could REALLY SING it - we need to believe her. Our group DID. NOT. Same with that Shelly.. Butler went for surface level schtick and forgot the character. The casting at City Center could have been better.

Updated On: 9/1/26 at 04:41 PM

#17

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

7thbighero said: "“Little Shop of Horrors satirizes many things: science fiction, ‘B’ movies, musical comedy itself, and the the Faust legend. There will, therefore, be a temptation to play it for camp and low-comedy. This is a great and potentially fatal mistake. The script keeps its tongue firmly in cheek, so the actors should not. Instead, they should play with simplicity, honesty, and sweetness--even when events are at their most outlandish. The show’s individual “style” will evolve naturally from the words themselves and an approach to acting and singing them that is almost child-like in its sincerity and intensity. By way of example, Audrey poses like Fay Wray from time to time. But she does this because she’s in genuine fear and happens to see the world as her private ‘B’ movie--not because she’s “commenting” to the audience on the the silliness of her situation. Having directed the original New York production of Little Shop myself, and subsequently having seen it in many versions and even many languages, I can vouch for the fact that when Little Shop is at its most honest, it is also at its funniest and most enjoyable.”

- Howard Ashman
"

There's a difference between playing the role straight and playing it seriously. Ellen Greene's Audrey was clearly a cartoon, but she played the cartoon earnestly and movingly (as well as hilariously). That's quite different than someone playing her as a realistic, three-dimensional woman trapped in an abusive relationship, which is another kind of character--and another kind of play--altogether. I haven't seen this produciton, so no comment on Wolfe or any of the other Audreys. Just pointing out that playing straight isn't the same thing as playing for street realism.

#18

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

It’s the difference between camp and kitsch. Little Shop is super high camp: the serious is treated with absurdity and the absurd treated as serious. The tricky part is that Audrey is a kitschy person, not a kitschy character.
#19

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

this is a very harsh subject to have out there on the board like this. why must people be so disrespectful? I have never been a particular fan of Betsy Wolfe but shes a person who doesnt deserve to see such cattiness on the front page of a message board.
#20

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

CoffeeBreak said: "Fred Mason said: "Kerry Butler was bad as Audrey for the same reasons she bad as Meredith in Bat Boy. She’s supposed to be soft spoken housewife in an unhappy marriage and she’s playing it like a womanon the verge of a nervous breakdown which is why she was so fabulous in Mean Girls and Heathers."

Not sure I agree with how she plays it. But she'd NOT GOOD as Meredith. They went for the "look she's an alum of the original" - and now all grown up. No one cares THAT much. They should have cast a fierce woman with real fire who could REALLY SING it - we need to believe her. Our group DID. NOT. Same with that Shelly.. Butler went for surface level schtick and forgot the character. The casting at City Center could have been better.
"

Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum joining forces on hating on Kerry Butler in Bat Boy has me fully convinced she's gonna win a Tony for it

As for next Audrey - I have heard an up-and-coming recent Tony nominee may be coming in...

#21

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

Ptero2 said: "As for next Audrey - I have heard an up-and-coming recent Tony nominee may be coming in..."

OMG! JUNE SQUIBB?!??


Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!! www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm
#22

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

quizking101 said: "Ptero2 said: "As for next Audrey - I have heard an up-and-coming recent Tony nominee may be coming in..."

OMG! JUNE SQUIBB?!??


"

Omg! I'd love to see this. 😂


Darreyl with an L!
#23

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

In all seriousness…Nichelle Lewis?


"You travel alone because other people are only there to remind you how much that hook hurts that we all bit down on. Wait for that one day we can bite free and get back out there in space where we belong, sail back over water, over skies, into space, the hook finally out of our mouths and we wander back out there in space spawning to other planets never to return hurrah to earth and we'll look back and can't even see these lives here anymore. Only the taste of blood to remind us we ever existed. The earth is small. We're gone. We're dead. We're safe." -John Guare, Landscape of the Body
#24

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

AC126748 said: "In all seriousness…Nichelle Lewis?"

Hot Take: I don’t find her all that appealing vocally. Shes fine but doesn’t knock my socks off. I take issue with her nomination for RAGTIME in the way I did for Joy Woods in GYPSY.

I would actually pay a mint to see Stephanie Hsu as Audrey. She just played the kewpie doll ingenue in ROCKY HORROR and has killer comedic instinct


Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!! www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm
#25

Re: Sorry Betsy Wolfe, Worst Audrey Ever

On paper, they are perfect for these roles, so I would place the blame on Mayer (whose production was never as funny as I’d like for Little Shop imho) and Austin Regan, the show’s resident director who rehearses all the replacements. Quality control on a long-running show can live and die with its resident director.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $65
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $71