Saw the show tonight, and have to say I was somewhat disappointed. The first scene of the first act was unbearably slow and long. The second scene was a startling switch in tone, pace, and quality; it was the only scene that absolutely blew me away. Basically, the show succeeds whenever its stars are alone onstage, or else when they’re allowed to carry the scene; whenever the ball is tossed to a member of the supporting cast, they drop it. The older gentlemen acquit themselves well, but Jacqueline McKenzie is pretty awful, Chris Ryan and Toby Schmitz effective only in fits and starts, and Anna Bamford barely registers. This should be a wild sex farce in which moments of genuine tragedy and profundity sneak up and surprise you; but the ensemble hasn’t a good grasp of the tone and pace. There are many moments which are played too silly, and many not nearly silly enough, the result being a kind of lumpy pudding of a play. The scene changes are rather long as well.
That said, I liked the script itself, which manages to seem fresh and new whilst capturing the spirit of Chekhov. It was definitely the ensemble’s fault. Of course, my main reason for wanting to see the show was Cate Blanchett, probably my favorite living actress, and by God she doesn’t disappoint. Hope she wins the Tony for this, it would be well deserved. The dance orgy scene is absolutely mesmerizing and hilarious, and her scene in the fog is incredibly moving. And Richard Roxburgh very nearly matches her; Blanchett excepted, the fog scene is basically a series of tiresome one-note monologues by the supporting cast, but Roxburgh saves us from boredom simply by sitting and smoking. They are both an endless pleasure to watch and listen to.
But overall I fear that the first section needs serious trimming, and the producers should’ve brought over their two leads but recast the remaining roles.