Posted: 8/4/23 at 10:57pm
Caught this at the very last minute tonight and I can say I was somewhat entertained but not overly impressed.
It plays out in a series of “behind the scenes” vignettes that just seemed to be based on a compilation of anecdotes tied together with the thread of “this is only happening because the shark is broken and we’re trying to kill time”. The interplay between Shaw and Dreyfuss feels like it’s own version of Mamet’s “A Life In The Theatre” (beleaguered veteran vs. cocky upstart) and Scheider feels relegated to the role of part referee/part news bulletin/part trivia nerd. Also, the very hacky jokes that jokingly foreshadow the times we live in (corrupt presidents, climate change, the loss of original IP) seemed to be done with a heavy wink and nod that I thought someone was gonna break the fourth wall.
I will say that all three performances were pitch perfect though down to the idiosyncrasies and mannerisms. Donnell has Scheider’s cadence and grounded body language down and it’s remarkably freaky how Ian Shaw can look and sound just like his father. However, Brightman steals the show (albeit that is tantamount to petty theft) by blending Dreyfuss’ cocksure attitude, diva behavior, and drug-fueled mania with his own brand of energetic physical and comedic delivery. His scene impersonating his costars was PERFECT and it made me think what he could do if he played all three characters at once.
Overall, I give this a 2.5/5. Great performances can’t mask that more than the shark is broken here…