For the unaware, and the just plain mean, when you click Reply, the site initially brings up a box that looks like this:

As you can see, this box doesn't have the options for Bold/Italics/bullet points/etc. at the top. This is a plain text box, so any link posted in it will be published as text rather than be converted to a link.
After a few seconds, the site is supposed to convert this text reply field into one that turns everything into HTML, with all the little options at the top. Any link posted in this box is automatically converted into a clickable link.

Therefore, if a nonclickable link was posted, that means that the site didn't convert over to the web formatting box before the poster pasted the link. This does happen every so often. When I'm posting reviews on opening nights I frequently have to wait for the right box to appear, and occasionally have to refresh the page entirely, or go back a page and hit Reply again. This is actually what I had to do just now in order to get these screenshots. After well over 30 seconds the box still hadn't converted, so I had to page back and hit Reply again.
That is not the fault of the poster, especially if they don't know they need to wait for the correct reply box to appear. I have to believe that no one deliberately posts an unclickable link. That would require them reverting the converted link back to plain text in the HTML box, which is absurd. Being a jerk on the other hand is usually quite deliberate.
Understood?