Not sure what to make of this. First time exposure to the show- i remember being a small kid and hearing about this cool "rock musical" by the Who, and it feels like since then the novelty of rock+opera+broadway has maybe worn off a bit? Not trying to take away from the revolutionary nature of this piece but it didnt really do much for me.
This is a very sleek production-- lots of silver bright lines and some impressive tight choreography. But its a bare-set-minimal-presentation sorta thing, and its pretty to look at, but with such an involved story, I kinda found myself having to guess what they were going for a bit too much. It feels like this is geared towards the people (and there were plenty there tonight) who are revisiting a classic and appreciating the new sleek spin on it. Im just not that guy.
One of the strangest parts to me was the role of Tommy-- Ali Bourzgi has an INCREDIBLE vocal tone and sings with real power/charisma. But am I nuts or is he a small supporting character in Act 1? I kept waiting for him to break out and show us Who Tommy Is (or Why He Is The Lead) but it didnt happen. Act 1 ends with a very strange Acid Queen visit, that is staged kinda underwhelmingly (they go to her, she suggests she can seduce/enlighten the boy, but then.... they leave her to herself?), and then we head into the big event- Pinball Wizard--which is a blast! but is again, Tommy free. This absence of Tommy-ness created too big a hole for Tommy to be able to fill in Act 2. And the score gets blander and more repetitive in Act 2, also, so i just felt underwhelmed.
The mezzanine was not full, and I actually thought the crowd was restless/bored a bit, but at the end of Act 2, in what i thought was a rather unremarkable moment, the cast stepped to the lip of the stage, and the audience LEAPT TO THEIR FEET applauding and screaming, so I was definitely in the minority in my bewilderment.
It wasnt all bad. I could listen to Bourzgi forever and hes giving a riveting, focused, performance. Production just seems to drown his character out a bit. I thought the only other interesting character (ie funny, exciting) was Bobby Conte's Cousin Kevin-- he sounds great, and I couldnt help but wonder where those powerful belts and vocals were in his Company solo. He was definitely a highlight tonight. (Shoutout also to Sheldon Henry whose voice snapped me to attention).
Des MacAnuff gave a self-indulgent speech to kick things off, but gave a nice shoutout/warning re the actors taking on roles on barely any notice. David Paul Kidder pulled it off subbing for Adam Jacobs, and if he missed any cues or lines, I didnt notice it. I thought both Captian and Mrs Walker were pretty thankless roles though. More kudos to Afra Hines, who looking at her bio I must have seen in the ensemble of 4-5 shows, a real pro, proving her worth and stepping into Acid Queen with total ease. Its a mess of a scene, but its tricky movement and some real singing, and I dont think you would have ever known it was her first night, let alone with minimal rehearsal.