Posted: 11/30/18 at 12:27am
I just re-read the book prior to seeing the show tonight, and I'm mixed on the adaption, but loved the production as a whole. I found a lot of the writing to be a bit heavy handed and obnoxious, and the ending felt tacked on, unskilled, and clunky. It felt like it kept trying to end on a very serious, impactful note and just couldn't quite figure out which note to land on.
I though the performances were all pretty fantastic except for Calpurnia. I think that character needs a quiet strength, and I felt the actress wanted to give us these big, explosive scenes, but they didn't need it. And felt like she had been directed to dial it back, but then didn't know what to do in those quieter moments.
I thought the actor playing Robinson was just fantastic. He had a small part, but just felt like that was a real, living, fleshed-out human being, and just really thought he was brilliant in his subtly.
The main cast was great, and I think they all suit their parts, but they didn't deliver anything I haven't seen them do before.
The design was weird. I didn't quite get the idea to set the whole thing in an abandoned warehouse type place. And why the interior of the house needed to rise from the floor, etc. I think it could have been a much more simpler design.
Also, side note for me, but we never actually see the jury in the court room, correct? I was confused because the stage left seating area had people, and the other one did not, which made it look like a jury. But there were people missing, etc.
Overall I thought Sorkin did a great job - "Strength and violence are no synonymous" - but I just wish the Boo Radley storyline had been handled better, and the staging more impactful.
Also, seating wise, I sat in the rear Mezz and HATED it. I hate the overhang, and I love seeing the design of the space, etc, and I just felt trapped. I wish I had opted for balcony. I didn't miss any of the action or anything, but everything felt cropped. And the curtain call was just looking at people's feet. I felt like I didn't quite get the scope of Sher's direction. I'll try and go back and sit in the balcony.