The photo of Amy really doesn't show what her wig really looks like. It actually appears to be inspired by a "Gibson Girl" style. It's a huge flat bun that encompasses her whole head and looks a bit like this:
I was actually at the first preview and haven't put my 2 or 5 cents in yet, so here goes:
Sure it was a sloppy, nerve-ridden first preview, but I really think that when all the kinks are worked out and all of the "tricks" are figured out and sped up, it'll blow people's minds.
Cast-wise, the stand-outs for me were as follows:
Jessie Mueller...that voice is unreal and the fact that she has such incredible, real acting chops to back up her glorious voice is all the more impressive to me.
As mentioned several times before, the unexpected direction that Sara Stiles takes with Little Red is hysterical, refreshing and kinda sexy at times after she "Know[s] Things Now." I also didn't hate Little Red by the end, which I usually do, so HOORAY!
Ok, now don't come after me, but Dennis O'Hare was such a perfect Baker. Sure he doesn't have the most beautiful voice, but his portrayal was really great. I thought he handled his wife's death very well, waiting to deal with his grief in private.
Jack's Mother is one of my all-time favorite characters in all of musical theatre. I'm not sure why, but just go with it. Kristine Zbornik did an excellent job of creating a fresh interpretation of the character, however her interpretation was very brash and one-note, which cause a lot of her great jokes to fall short or even flat (which is consistent with several actors in this production)
Not much to say about these two, but two characters that usually don't leave much of an impact (Rapunzel and Cinderella's Stepmother) were more defined and impressive than I'd ever seen them, thanks to Tess Soltau and Ellen Harvey.
We all knew Donna would bring it and she sure did, it was just a little underwhelming that none of her choices seemed to surprise me. Most everything she did seemed like something I expected. And it was, of course, the first preview and she'll discover more as the run goes on. As for her mask that grows after each midnight, I definitely prefer the one here to the London one. For the majority of Act I her face is visible, which I much prefer to the Regent's Park production where 3/4 of her face was covered the whole time.
Amy Adams came off very musical-theatre-y and just not very real. Which is odd, because what I usually love about her film performances is her humanity and real-ness. First preview, she'll grow, blah blah blah.
The two princes were so typical for such an "out there, innovative" production. If you're going to take different directions with the character interpretations, why leave out the princes? I really loved how they handled the princes in London. Same with Gideon Glick as Jack. He was cute, sure, but nothing special like Ben Stott in the Regent's Park production.
Costume-wise, I felt like all of the costumes were coming from their own world. INTO THE WOODS is a mash-up of various fairy tales, but it is a cohesive story and I think the costumes should reflect that. I think that with some costumes and moments of direction, they sacrificed the original book and loyalty to the world to be innovative and edgy.
I wasn't a huge fan of The Baker from the London production, but one of the things that really stood out to me from that production was the obvious tension and need for a child that came from he and The Baker's Wife's performances and relationship. You could tell that they were not in a happy marriage and that this child was absolutely necessary to help mend the marriage. I didn't feel that tension or necessity from Amy Adams or Denis O'Hare.
Overall, I had a great time, but think tightening, more specificity and staying closer to the book that works SO well are necessary.
"These rabid fans...possess the acting talent to portray the hooker...Linda Eder..." -The New York Times