Got into the show tonight by doing the cancellation line. Only me and 1 other person ended up getting into the performance because everybody with tickets showed up, on a Wednesday night none-the-less. I believe I was in Duncan Sheik's seat because he wasn't at the performance and I was sitting with the creative team, sandwiched between Lynn Nottage and Sam Gold (living the dream, right?).
Really loved the show. It's a very traditional classic book-musical with just top-notch material. Lynn's book is wonderful and Sheik's score and orchestrations are beautiful. The material isn't perfect by any means, but it's in fantastic shape. And I'm sure they'll continue to edit through the entire preview process to get it to where it ultimately needs to be.
My major criticisms lay in the musical numbers, and particularly with the lyrics. Not all of the time, but occasionally it felt like the lyrics and music weren't matching up with each other in terms of content and style. I felt that most in the songs between Lily and Zach ("what do you love most" song, the reprise in the car, and the song after Zach gets out of jail), but also I think those songs could be cut entirely and turned into scene work, especially with Nottage as your book writer. The duet between Lily and Zach was also in a very weird key, where it was almost too low for her and it was way too high for him. They need to change the melody, change the key, or add a key change to make it work (or just cut the duet which is my preference).
I wished that the opening number was different, or played differently. It didn't feel like it perfectly setup the tone of the rest of the play, especially with how many major chords Sheik wrote in. I wanted dissonance, I wanted something that would hint at the racial tensions other than the lyrics "It's hot."
Someone mentioned earlier that there was a song in the show about a movie star, which wasn't in the show tonight. Sounds like it got the axe.
What I loved most in the show, other than Nottage's book, was Sheik's incidental music. His music is stunning in the show, and I'm so glad his shows are taking off again. If anything, I know that with any Sheik show I'll be in love with his music. His uses of the banjo, harmonium, djembe, violin, and piano are all wonderful and creative.
Was talking with a potential producer before the show, during intermission, and afterwards, and it sounds like this thing has the thumbs up on moving next season as long as they have a theater they can move into. The buzz is getting really big with this one, and the material is definitely worthy of it.