NJ_BroadwayGirl said: "aaaaaa15 said: "Americans don't love Hamilton because it's about America, that's just a bonus. They love it because it's good. "
I agree that the story is universal and the fever pitch surrounding the show is because it's good. I agree that people outside the US will want to see it and enjoy it. It's not like all of the people clamoring to see it are American history buffs. But I will say that Hamilton's immigrant, pulled up by his boot straps story is very American as is the Revolutionary War aspect.
It may be subconscious for some people, but I believe part of the reason people here love the show has to do with that Revolutionary War hero aspect and the building of our country, especially during such turbulent political times. I was surprised by how deeply moved I was to view our founding fathers as young men, wild and passionate and willing to give everything for freedom (as opposed to how they appear in history books, all serious and powdery). So while I predict it will be popular elsewhere, the passion among the fans may not grow quite as strong.
I agree with you. Yes music is great and transcends; yes many aspects of his story are universal. And yet, it is a uniquely "American" story and one we all connect to as Americans. So, it will be interesting to see the extent to which it is well received. It will be well received, but I just don't think insanely so as here.
"