The Thread for HAMILTON Fans/Obsessives [SPOILERS AHEAD] — Page 62

I'm not sure there is a way to link to a Snapchat, but if you don't follow Oak (sn OakSmash) you might want to check out his latest. If I were a betting woman, I'd say Jasmine Cephas-Jones will be making a quiet exit from the show tonight or tomorrow.

https://twitter.com/achapphawk/status/805234583553703937



I guess she will be leaving soon

sparepart973 said: I'm seeing the Chicago company next week and can't wait to compare notes.

Based on your review of the current NY show, I suspect you will find the Chicago production better -- the casting process for the OC of the Chicago show appears to have been more rigorous than for the replacement casting in NY.

"

sparepart973 said: "In terms of Hamilton's squad, Jordan Fisher gives the most polished and complete performance. He really was excellent and delivered beautifully. With Seth Stewart, I felt like he gave someone else's performance, although his Jefferson in Act II is more his. Unfortunately, I feel that he has little natural charm or charisma. The problem with Jevon McFerrin (who I found very very attractive, above all) is that he, Seth Stewart and Nicholas Christopher are all the same prototype, and all came across kind of "samey" in how they looked."

Who was McFerrin on as?

"Not specifically impressed by any of the lead ladies. Mandy Gonzalez is not as dynamic as I thought she'd be, and Lexi is practically invisible."

Were you there last night? Who played Peggy/Maria?

Updated On: 12/10/16 at 01:24 PM

Was at the Public today and noticed the old-timey Hamilton cast photos have been taken down (off the wall of the lounge that overlooks the lobby).

TotallyEffed said: "Does anyone know when Karen will leave the Chicago production?



If I am not mistaken, I remember someone on here said that she was only contracted for 6 months, which would put her as leaving in February or March. I don't know how true that is though, so don't quote me on that.

That's why I said " I don't know how true that is ", neonlightsxo.

For those of us with tix in the distant future...I wonder how long he's staying...

I saw the sit-down production in Chicago a few days ago (and will tomorrow too).

Wow, what a stellar production. First class casting and lightyears ahead of the Broadway cast.

Miguel Cervantes as Hamilton is excellent and full of energy. He's a very small man, which adds a lot to his need to be noticed and to be seen. He's in his mid-30s, so unlike, Michael Luwoye who plays a much younger Hamilton, the line "arrogant, obnoxious" as described by Burr totally works.

Burr was played by a giant of a man, Mr. Carl Clemons Hopkins who was understudying for Josh Henry that afternoon. Great acting, fine singing. I was nervous how he'd move during Room Where it Happens because he does't have your usual dancer's build, let alone towering over all the ensemble members (especially Hamilton, so the competition becomes even more interesting!). He danced it just fine..I was surprised to find out after the show that this was Carl's debut performance as Burr. My friend noticed that during the curtain call some cast members patted him and gave him a round of applause, I must have been looking somewhere else.

Karen Olivo as Anglica..Magic. I knew that something was off and boring about Mandy Gonzales's Angelica, and it became more evident seeing Karen tackle this. Layers over layers of characterization, fantastic details to her performance and just a natural fountain of charisma.

Alexander Gemignani as King George is marvelous. I liked Rory O'Malley (and the videos I've seen of La Groff), but I have to say Alexander has put in so much thought and work into this. He is rather crazy from the get-go, and just keeps on getting more manic as the show continues.

Ari Afrsar sounds like a young Nora Jones, and she is instantly likelable and sympathetic, without being a boring and helpless. Totally made me shed a tear at the end.

I hope this doesn't sound defensive, but I wrote a short blurb on the Broadway cast a few pages ago. I think "analysis" is overselling what I've put together. It's just a basic stream of my top thoughts and takeaway from my recent outing. Not here to write a critic-like review.

Andy51 said: "sparepart973 said: "I hope this doesn't sound defensive, but I wrote a short blurb on the Broadway cast a few pages ago. I think "analysis" is overselling what I've put together. It's just a basic stream of my top thoughts and takeaway from my recent outing. Not here to write a critic-like review.

I get that, but given that (a) Hamilton and Burr are the two most prominent roles in the musical and (b) you did not see the principal actor for Hamilton (Munoz) in NY or for Burr (Henry) in Chicago, you simply are not in a position to make such sweeping statements about casting.





"

Well, seeing Joshua Henry would have only bolstered the argument.

Here's how I compare the OBC (minus Groff) to the current Chicago cast. The current Broadway cast seems a bit boring/cobbled together to me, but that's 100% speculation on my part.

To be clear, I thought every actor listed below was great even if I preferred someone else in the role.



Lin vs. Miguel: Lin (except the singing)

Leslie vs. Josh: Equal, both are better in certain ways (I prefer Leslie's Wait for It, specifically), but at the end of the day I pick Josh

Phillipa vs. Ari: Equal (I think most would choose Phillipa, but I prefer Ari's more relaxed Eliza)

Renee vs. Karen: Renee for the singing in Schuyler Sisters and Satisfied, Karen for acting and It's Quiet Uptown

Chris vs. Jonathan: Chris

Daveed vs. Chris: Daveed, the unicorn

Oak v. Wallace: Oak Mulligan (except for Wallace's "come again"!), Wallace Madison

Anthony vs. Jose: equal, slight edge to Anthony for star quality

Jasmine vs. Samantha: slight edge to Samantha

Rory vs. Alex: Alex by a mile

Other roles: Chicago; Jin Ha and Jose Amor are standouts

Andy51 said: ""Well, seeing Joshua Henry would have only bolstered the argument."

So, you've seen both Dixon and Henry, and you think Henry is "lightyears ahead of" Dixon? Seems highly dubious to me that Henry could be so much better (if he's better at all) than Dixon given how good Dixon is.



"

Oh, I haven't seen Dixon and have no plans to; I just meant that if the poster had seen Josh Henry, I guarantee that any comments about the Chicago cast would have been even more "sweeping." That's all. I don't really care about the "light years" thing, as this wasn't a legal brief but rather an excited recap of a musical theater experience.