Posted: 12/20/16 at 7:02pm
I just saw the NY cast (all replacements except for Oak) and also saw the Chicago cast last month. I agree with most of the sentiments above that the Chicago cast blows NY replacements away. If I go down the list of characters:
Hamilton- Cervantes much better than Luowye.
Burr- Henry slightly better than Dixon.
Washington - Kirkland lightyears ahead of Treco (s/b). The physical height disparity between Kirkland and Cervantes was so striking and effective.
Lafayette/Jefferson- Stewart couldn't come close to Lee's energy. Stewart is definitely the weak link in the NY cast while Lee is one of the highlights in Chicago.
King George - Gemignani did slightly better than O'Malley.
Eliza - Afsar brought sweetness and power at the right times, Lawson was fairly wooden.
Angelica- I didn't like either especially but Olivo's It's Quiet Uptown performance was gut-wrenching.
Laurens/Phillip - This was the closest matchup. I might even give a slight edge to Fisher since he is so physically suited for the role and knows his comedic timing.
Hercules/Mulligan - Also kind of a tie.
Anyways, it's safe to say that I wish they were a bit more discerning about finding Broadway replacements. Although I didn't have the special experience of seeing the OBC, the Chicago production will definitely hold a fond place in my heart.
Updated On: 12/20/16 at 07:02 PM