I saw the show last night as well and am still collecting my thoughts, but I loved this production, especially Metcalf, whom we may as well just rename the Best Actress in a Play Tony the "Laurie award" because she is giving a fully lived-in Martha that is bold, low-class, SEXUAL, hilarious, yet vulnerable and is truly mesmerizing to watch.
She is the first Martha I've seen (Turner, Morton, Staunton) that I truly bought the seduction of Nick. She looks great and isn't afraid to use her body. I fully believed Tovey wanted to sleep with her for the fun of it as well as the job perks it would create. They had wonderful chemistry. Heck, I even bought she wanted to sleep with George at points. She also seemed to be enjoying George's taunts and names, genuinely laughing and egging him on at the start.
The direction is again top-notch from Mantello who really gets to the heart of great actors. They are all giving great performances that feel nuanced and not gimmicky or broad. The night starts out with Metcalf very much in sitcom mode, getting laugh after laugh, performing such great physical comedy, but as the night goes on, more and more gets stripped away dropping both her ability to laugh at things and her desire to to make others laugh. How she treats the heart-break of George's words in act 2 (the "at daddy's party!" speech) was taken to a new place I've never seen it played before. Instead of blind rage and a throaty scream she changes to a shrieking headvoice. Needless to say George's final attack on her left me gobsmacked, I honestly felt like time stood still when she heard and processed the news.
I thought Everett was very good, playing the role a bit more forceful from the beginning that I like, but still a very mannered and funny performance, same with Patsy Ferran. Tovey was my only disappointment, but his American accent always distracts me.