I saw Part I the evening before opening, and if it was a Saturday and Hedwig had a showing at 10pm, I'd have walked out at intermission and ran to get a ticket to something I would have enjoyed more. I found it to be a dull show that's unnecessarily long yet still somehow manages to leave out large portions of the historical narrative. I love this era of history, but this was just downright boring in my opinion.
I considered Anne Boleyn's acting to be average, although her lack of stage time in Part I made it impossible to develop her character fully. I think the majority of the fault lies in the book. It's too long and has too many characters to develop any of them fully. Even after three long hours of theatre, I'm still not quite clear on what Wolf Hall's Cromwell has for a motivation. He switches between ambition and seeming to just wish to survive repeatedly. I suspect that's more an issue with the book than an issue with the acting.
On the other hand, the actor playing King Henry VIII did an excellent job. The minimalist staging and direction were the highlight of the evening - I doubt they could have done a better job in that department.
I'm undecided on whether I'll go back for Part II, but I suspect not. There are too many good shows opening at this time of the year for me to waste half a trip to the city on seeing a play for the sake of completion.
BROADWAY: The Cripple of Inishmaan, This is Our Youth, If/Then, Hedwig and the Angry Inch (x3), Cabaret (x2), The Real Thing, A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder, Chicago, Les Miserables (x2) Disgraced, Finding Neverland, On the Twentieth Century, Wolf Hall Part I, On the Town, Fun Home; TOURING: Jekyll and Hyde, The Book of Mormon; LOCAL: The Twilight Zone, Anne Boleyn, Death and the Maiden, The Lying Kind, Chorus Line, Stupid F**king Bird