I ended up catching what I believe was the second preview of this show tonight on impulse. Let me start by saying that I think it is quite overwhelming to see a fully staged musical after SO long and I had slightly forgot that the magic of live theatre is like nothing else - watching the energetic choreography, passionate cast, funky costumes and set move before your eyes with an enthusiastic audience beside you does not compare to any other medium of story telling in my opinion and it is so good to be back. I can only imagine how exciting it will be to be in some of the early Broadway audiences soon.
During curtain call Michael Ball gave a brief speech to the effect of:
“You cannot imagine how great it feels to hear that sound again [of the audience cheering]. And you’re doing twice the work [because it is a socially distanced audience at less than 50% capacity]. Spread the word. The west end is back.”
Again, just overwhelming, especially after what might be the most catchy and energetic ending of a musical I have ever seen or heard with “You Can’t Stop The Beat”, which can easily make you forgive anything that came before it.
Other highlights include Marisha Wallace whose performance of “I Know Where I’ve Been” was the most authentic and musically virtuosic performance of the night, which had a standing ovation from most of the audience - I can’t recall if I’ve seen this happen in London (more common on Broadway). In the right year this could be a Tony Award winning featured actress performance.
Out of the white characters, Michael Ball’s performance was also surprisingly the most authentic in my opinion, with “You’re Timeless To Me” in particular being a heartfelt, hilarious showstopper. I can’t help but wonder if he might have had a little more energy 13 years ago in the role, but it was still a highlight.
The show itself, well I assume most people are familiar with it here - I think it’s quite interesting because it feels like a frivolous candy (fairy) floss mid-19th century Broadway musical (not even up to Rodgers & Hammerstein level in terms of timescale) yet this sugary treat is cleverly peppered with enough fresh catchy songs, edgy one-liners and beef stock of social progress themes that it manages to be both highly entertaining and meaningful at the same time. It doesn’t scream, shout or shock you into wanting change - it doesn’t try and pull at your emotions (cf. The Color Purple or Caroline, or Change) - it just makes you feel like your friends are dancing on that stage and you want society to progress because you want what is best for them. Maybe not as dramatically interesting as the more 'serious' shows but highly effective.
If I were to try and think of negatives, I would say it is overamplified and while the show is kind of a cartoon, I wondered if much of the cast are playing at 150% right now and could bring it down a little to 100% - because it came across as a little inauthentic and shrieky from some of the cast. I haven’t seen the show on stage before and it’s not one of my favs so I can’t tell if this is just the aesthetic of the show though. At the very least, you could be sitting at the back of the very top level and still feel the cast is playing to you!
The set felt right for an average mid-size musical - not particularly lavish or too simple either. I would not be surprised if it was based on a touring scale, but I don’t think the set is the point of the show to me - it’s not Moulin Rogue.
Overall, would highly recommend and it does feel like the right show for Broadway right now.
Finally, I will continue to beat a dead horse and I don’t think you should expect anything less (or more, rather) from me or this forum, but THIS was the role that Bernadette lost her Tony for in Gypsy?
Give me claws and a hunch, just away from this bunch.
Updated On: 6/22/21 at 06:16 PM