ON THE TOWN Reviews- Page 4

[devonian.t]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 1:55pm

So glad to see a Broadway classic get the classic revival it deserves.

I hope to see it next Spring!

[HorseTears]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 2:23pm

PJ? Review??

[PalJoey]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 3:43pm

I'm still flying from what a joyous evening this production of On the Town was. To hear Lenny's score played by 28 pieces and conducted with Lenny-like verve by James Moore--and sung by such a flawlessly talented cast...to have John Rando's direction land with every Comden and Green joke down to the silliest word-play and then luxuriate in the exquisite anguish of those Bernstein ballads. It's all almost too much goodness...

It was a night of one showstopper after another. I can't remember how many of the numbers got show-stopping applause: the "New York, New York" sequence, the Miss Turnstiles ballet (twice--once when the Ivy-as-winner section ended, and then again when the ballet concluded), the "Come Up to My Place" in which the performers and the projections were perfectly in sync resulting in a dazzling tour de force!), the Carried Away sequence, the gasp-inducing "Lonely Town" song/pas de deux/chorale, "I Can Cook Too," the entrancing "Lucky to Be Me" and the Times square Ballet!

I remember feeling at intermission at Barrington that I didn't want the second act to start. I wanted them to start all over again from the top of the show and do the first act a second time and THEN go on to the second act. I had never felt like that at a musical before. I felt it even more so last night.

Greatest new thing first: The a capella chorale of "Lonely Town" with Gabey onstage and members of the cast dotted around the audience, singing harmony...that was a coup de théâtre that would make Lenny and Adolph weep with joy--and turn to Jerry Robbins and say "Why didn't YOU think of that, Mr. Genius!"

A musical with 4 ballets--how outrageous that was in 1944!--but all of Jerome Robbins's choreography was lost. So how miraculous is it that Josh Bergasse was able to mix storytelling and comedy and ballet and jazz--in EXACTLY the alchemical combination that Jerry Robbins loved to mix? The dramatic dances, the comic dances, the movements for the non-dancing actors...all pitch perfect. Generally, Robbins Purists walk away from these things muttering "Well, it's not Jerry," but I guarantee that they're all saying "Jerry would have loved this."

And the cast, my god! Tony Yazbeck is everything Lenny and Jerry dreamed about when they thought about mixing drama and dance and music and comedy--he is Lenny and Jerry's ideal triple threat, from the way he communicates exuberance to the way he sings about heartache to way he moves through the air. And what a genius move it was to cast opposite him a genuine ballet star as Ivy! Megan Fairchild's dancing is also part of that artistic dream that Lenny and Jerry shared: taking something or someone from the concert world or the opera or the ballet and mixing it in with theater. She is adorable, and the chemistry she creates with Tony during the Gabey the Great Lover ballet is possibly the most erotic theatrical scene I have ever witnessed onstage.

Each of the other four principals reaches such heights of comic genius that my laughter occasionally disturbed the tired businessman in front of me. (Sorry, mister. I couldn't stop laughing.) I loved the way Jay Armstrong Johnson's adorable Chip literally fell head over heels--literally, backflips, and several times--for Alysha Umphress's Hildy. His pratfalls and her bawdiness are exactly the kind of silly, giddy comedy that Betty and Adolph and Lenny and Jerry enjoyed and appreciated and knew had to be part of musical comedy.

As for Alysha's vocal pyrotechnics, those who knew Lenny know he loved jazz and swing and bebop. And as someone who was once challenged by Lenny to join him in Ella Fitzgerald's scat version of "Lady Be Good" (which Lenny could perform in its entirety--I could barely keep up), I can say with my own authority that Lenny would have eaten Alysha Umphress up with a serving spoon. And, oh, but Betty and Adolph would have just adored the way Elizabeth Stanley and Clyde Alves make Claire and Ozzie the dizzy, zany comedic ballast of the entire show. How Betty would have smiled at Elizabeth's dazzling combination of high notes and low comedy! And Adolph would have hissed that "Yes! YeS!" at Clyde's antics about four dozen times.

And then Elizabeth and Alysha and Clyde and Jay break our hearts with a gorgeous and simple "Some Other Time"...just the way the show is supposed to break our hearts, but maybe we're a little more shattered in this revival precisely because the comedy is so zany.

There's even more skillful comedy from the twisted Allison Guinn and the insane Stephen De Rosa and the great Michael Rupert, who has been an important part of my theatergoing life since Pippin and Falsettos.

And then there's Madame Jackie Hoffman, who long ago entered comedy heaven. She may be an acquired taste--like kishkes and schmaltz--but once tasted, all she has to do is look your way, and you burp. I mean, laugh.

But there's one real star of the show and that's the score. The moment Philip Boykin began the first notes of the first song--in a awe-inspiring bass-baritone that would have melted Lenny into a puddle--I began to sob. The score is so beautiful and so full of joy, it was written by a man who would be known soon as a genius, he was surrounded by collaborators who were friends as well and in whose talent he believed devoutly, and they all wrote a musical that spoke an eternal truth: "Unless there's love, the world's an empty place."

Updated On: 10/18/14 at 03:43 PM

[Tigger]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 3:57pm

Bravo PJ. A stupendous, beautifully articulated, thoughtful and heartfelt review. I couldn't agree with you more.

[everythingtaboo]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 4:20pm

Beautifully said, PJ. I'm seeing it again for the third time tonight, and for all the reason you said and more, I really cannot wait to enjoy it all over again.

[PalJoey]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 4:33pm

Third time! You're so lucky to be you ;-}

[NYadgal]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 4:35pm

PalJoey - your reviews are what keep me coming back to BWW.

I thought about you all night. And love your review.
xo

[devonian.t]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 4:47pm

I agree- it's a pleasure to read such an insightful review.

[Baileyboo]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 5:00pm

Pal Joey-

That is the most amazing piece of theater related writing I have ever read. Email me when you are ready for a return visit.

[sing_dance_love]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 5:52pm

Oh, PJ... Thank you for sharing your passion with us. This board and this world is a better place for it.

It's so powerful feeling Lenny, Betty, Adolph, and Jerry's magic still reaching us today and in such vibrant form!

Bravo to Rando, Bergasse, cast, and company. The show is a marvel.

[HorseTears]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 5:57pm

PJ reviews. Worth the wait.

[ljay889]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 6:06pm

I am looking forward to seeing this production! It's nice to see a lot of enthusiasm surrounding a revival. It's not fun being a strong supporter of a revival and having others crap on it every chance they get.

[PalJoey]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 6:52pm

I wouldn't know what you're talking about ;-}

[DottieD'Luscia]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 8:54pm

I am beyond bummed that I couldn't make the trip up to NYC today to see this, and I had a great seat, too.

[Feste]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 10:52pm

That was a delight to read, PJ... thank you so much. I'm even more excited now to see this, in two more weeks!!

[After Eight]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 10:59pm

I fully expected at the end of Pal Joey's protracted joke of a post, (psst, PJ, remember, the most effective jokes are short and sweet), that our pal would scream, "April Fool!"

But then my calendar tells me it's October.

I guess jokers -- and their lame jokes --- can pop up any time of the year.

[Kad]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 11:04pm

"I guess jokers -- and their lame jokes --- can pop up any time of the year."

Great way to end a post that's just a lame joke, or greatest way to end a post that's just a lame joke?

[starcatchers]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 11:13pm

PJ. This made me smile.

[Sally Durant Plummer]

Posted: 10/18/14 at 11:30pm

A town must be a lonely town unless there's love, right Ben?

PJ - You have made me so excited to see this show. Your reviews are so fantastic and well-written. I knew you would love it from the first preview, but got a little antsy waiting for opening. Your words made than wait worthwhile! Hope you see it many times to come.

[Musical Master]

Posted: 10/19/14 at 12:14am

PJ- That was one of the reasons why I have finally decided to join the boards, reading your reviews and such wonderous joy it gives me makes life worthwhile. You are a class of your own PalJoey, a real class indeed.

Can't wait for THE KING AND I to come out and hear what you have to say about it. :)

[Greekmusicalfan]

Posted: 10/19/14 at 7:37am

A little off-topic and personal but please allow me this.

I will never forget that I owe PJ, one of the best theatrical experiences I've ever had. Back in 2008, I was not a big Patti fan and he persuaded me to go and see Gypsy, which I was on the fence about. I was mesmerised and fell completely in love with her and the show ! Since ON THE TOWN has his heartfelt approval, there is no way I am missing it on my January trip because I trust his taste and judgement completely. ( And hope I have the pleasurable chance to have coffee with him again !)

[PalJoey]

Posted: 10/19/14 at 10:31am

Of course we'll have coffee!

Sometimes things come together for a performer or a show and theatrical magic happens. Not always, but when it does, we should grab it.

I just got my King and I tickets, again for the night after the opening. It's my favorite of the Rodgers & Hammerstein shows and with the team they've put together, I'm betting it will be some more of that theatrical magic.

[LimelightMike]

Posted: 10/19/14 at 10:38am

PJ - What a beautiful review! You attended the 17th? Where were you sitting?

[PalJoey]

Posted: 10/19/14 at 11:02am

Row P on the aisle, house right, inches away from where Philip Boykin was standing during the Lonely Town chorale.

Where were you? I hope you weren't the tired businessman who thought I was laughing too loud!

[Princeton78]

Posted: 10/19/14 at 9:40pm

Any thoughts on front row tix for this show? On the left or right side of the orchestra? Too close?