Posted: 12/5/23 at 7:15pm
I caught the show this past Sunday (December 2). As everyone agrees, Jasmine Amy Rogers delights and dazzles as Boop. The dancing is terrific. A lot of the stage craft impresses (Grampy's invention, that chair, leads to a "how did that do that?" moment). I enjoyed the work of Ainsley Melham and Stephen DeRosa and the ensemble in general. Many of the songs are in great shape with "Where I Wanna Be" a fabulous act one closer. It's funny--people compare it to Barbie--it reminded me at times of Xanadu.
The book though is all over the place. And there are two things that stuck out at me. Betty keeps talking about how in her cartoons she's chased around until she bops a guy on the head. Why not show this in the first act? We are being told, not shown. Why not have a montage of her doing this again and again? That would make some events in Act Two stronger.
Also Melham's love interest character is a guy who loves old-style jazz. He's practically a Gene Kelly in On the Town or Cover Girl (the latter served as an inspiration to Xanadu with Kelly playing his Cover Girl character) kind of throwback. However I have questions...spoilers...
He wants to play in a club where Cab Calloway and Louis Armstrong on the wall. So when he tells Betty later in the show that he hasn't seen her film shorts because he likes the new, not the old, it doesn't make much sense. Why doesn't he simply say he doesn't like cartoons? And then could cause a crisis where he has to open his mind and take her work seriously?
The show bends over backwards being a tribute to modern day NYC. And that was cute.
Overall I had a good time. And as a light entertainment with some good (if generic) messages about being yourself, it's a pleasant show. People have compared it to the rather flawed Thoroughly Modern Millie and I have to agree. I got the same absolute joy watching Rogers as I did watching Sutton Foster, and the same "what a delightful leading man" feeling while watching Melham as I did while watching Gavin Creel.
Updated On: 12/5/23 at 07:15 PM