Most of the regular posters here have seen about 50 times more musicals than me, so just a few comments.
It was a sweet and gentle night at City Center. Although I had never seen Brigadoon, I was pleased that I knew most of the songs, especially the love songs sung so tenderly by Kelli and Patrick. I doubt that Steven Pasquale could have played and sung the role any better, although some still mesmerized by the musical performances in Bridges might have received a visceral thrill just by the recoupling of Kelli and Steven.
The revelation for me was Stephanie J. Block. Silly things like a name (although I believe that there is a reason for the inclusion of the 'J'
and some very sober still photos did not leave me prepared for her wonderful portrayal of the saucy dairymaid. She had two songs and I could have had more of her. I expect the critics will take notice.
To Ben and me, Kelli O'Hara can do no wrong. But I think that as the leading actress she saw less stage time than the leading actress usually does. I believe I got that impression because a great deal of time was consumed by the dance of the ensemble.
I'm usually not very fond of ballets breaking out in the middle of a musical, but here the dance just flowed from the plot and I was quite amazed that they could have put together such intricate movement in such a short period of time.
Still, if I had one wish for Brigadoon, it would be to cut back on the dance a bit and give us more of the song and dialog of the principals.
The cherry on top: theater employees circulating during intermission with trays of shortbread cookies and passing them out to all. Imagine that. A New York theater giving you something to eat for free.