VintageSnarker said:
RE: Frozen
It doesn't have the dramatic difficulties of The Little Mermaid (wheelies) or Tarzan but do you think Frozen would still be doing well at the box office if they'd put more effort into the sets and creating a sense of magic/wonder/magnitude on stage? The successful Disney stage adaptations seem to preserve the sense of spectacle."
I personally think that Frozen Broadway has a few key problems. First of these is fact that it is a journey-based narrative, and those don’t play well on stage, as the confines of the stage limit the scope of the story, and by extension the arcs of the characters. In addition, the sets and colour schemes are too drab, and need to be revised for London and other venues. Frozen 2 also looks like it is going for the “deeper and darker” approach, but it has a brighter, more varied colour scheme which contrasts with Frozen Broadway’s blacks, whites and blues. Furthermore, the loss of most of the action scenes from the original film reduces the spectacle and has the side effect of making the leads seem weaker. Would you rather watch the Princess Anna who fights off wolves singlehandledly, or the one who just grabs onto Kristoff when he almost falls off a bridge?
However, the greatest problem with Frozen Broadway is the fact that it wants to closely replicate a film that had a load of flaws but succeeded because it felt unique and different. Michael Grandage seems to regard Frozen as being like the Shakespeare he is so used to adapting, but it REALLY doesn’t have the depth of the Bard’s works. What it does have are great songs, pretty visuals and a willingness to take risks and chances. When Frozen was released, those qualities made it the right film at the right time, and ensured it could win over even those who hated Disney films. However, as the novelty of the film has worn off, its flaws have become more apparent, and sticking so close to the text just makes everyone aware of this...
It’s inevitable that Frozen won’t be on Broadway this time next year, so the question is how well it will do on Drury Lane. Shrek did better in the West End then it did on Broadway, but that was because they made a number of changes and edits. Hopefully, the Frozen team will revise the production for the West End as well...