Yesterday the second cover for Florence was on for her (I believe) second performance: Samantha Pollino. Stellar, in every way. Menzel-like pipes, and a Laura Osnes quality (at her best, i.e. Bandstand) in her presentation and her beautifully modulated upper register. I thought she worked especially well with Tveit. But then, I find Tviet to be doing some of the best work of his B'way career. IHere, in the most defined role in the show - original and even the unsuccessful Strong adjustment - he finds a soulful inner life that amplifies Rice's backstory for the literally traumatized character. In his 40s, Tveit still looks a decade younger until the videos begin; the contrast between the maturity and pain in his eyes and the younger body jerks the character into sharp focus, and by "Pity the Child," almost definitive, it's clear that he is giving a dimensional musical theater performance.
Yet ... yet as a show.... At this relatively late date, I'll join the chorus of naysayers who can't validate Strong's 10-12 years of work. Every point raised against it I support. The topical interpolations feel cheap, unearned, and insult both everyone who's toiled on this flawed piece for decades and the NY audience. A choir that knows damn well what we're enduring in 2025-2026. By the time we get to an ageist Biden quip - which did not land yesterday - I felt for the gifted actor forced to spill it. That said, and not a contradiction, the MVP is Pinkham, who is mesmerizing, delivering a charismatic point of access, and who handles the score, the weirdly robotic choreography, and the Strong wise-ass narrative with triple-threat savvy.
I have thoughts on the still unsuccessful character of Florence, which I'll post separately.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling