Posted: 4/9/26 at 9:17am
I decided to wait a bit to see this based on the early reports that they might need some more time to find their characters and get the tone right and I'm glad I did. Last night, there was nothing to indicate any of the actors were in different shows, they were all uniformly brilliant.
The mark of not just good actors but great actors is when they can take a piece like this, one that's been done countless times before by some of the best to ever live, and make those words seem like they were written for them and being spoken for the very first time. That's what Nathan Lane and Laurie Metcalf are doing at The Winter Garden and it's kind of astounding to witness. I agree that the show isn't at all swallowed up here and that's a feat in itself, on this stage and even moreso highlights the towering performances being given that they can fill the space.
As much praise as I can put on those two, equal praise needs to be given to Christopher Abbott who, in that last scene, broke my heart more than any actor has done in quite a while. I don't think I've ever cried like that during that scene (or this play) but he broke me. In fact, when I talk about this production to people 10, 15 years from now, that might be the first thing I'll remember about it, I just know it's going to live in my head for the rest of my life.
"Death of a Salesman" has always been known as one of, if not the greatest American play ever written and Mantello's production perfectly shows why that's true.