Posted: 3/8/26 at 12:07am
I was at tonight’s second preview (ran about 2:55), and I quite adored this.
I went into it expecting to love both lead performances, but also knowing that structurally, this was Willy’s story. That being said, while Nathan Lane is truly brilliant, Laurie Metcalf walks away with the show. Her Linda is stoic, terrified, loving, and cold all at once. The “Attention must be paid” scene was electric.
But again, Lane is doing some career-best work here, and his chemistry with Metcalf is terrific. The balance does not feel thrown off, but this production almost makes a case for the play being a two-hander, though I do believe Metcalf will be nominated (and win) as Featured Actress.
Christopher Abbott started off a little pensive to me, but definitely grew as the night went on, and ended up faring very well in his onstage sparring with Lane. Ben Ahlers was a terrific Happy, and definitely made up for Abbott’s lack of spark in their first scene. I also want to shout out the always-terrific K. Todd Freeman, who absolutely nails his handful of scenes as Charley.
The physical production was gorgeous, particularly the lighting and the score. Mantello is truly the best director of actors working right now. For a second preview of a famously long play, the pacing was impressively tight. I definitely want to see this again later in the run when the performances have sharpened, but I anticipate this will be a major hit.