Primed to love this show when we see it this Saturday night. I've loved the design/staging approaches that Sher/ Yeargan have taken with some of their shows (Piazza... South Pacific); I've been disappointed in the minimalist approach they've taken with others: (King & I, Bridges...). I'll go with an open mind.
But Musical Master asks "Was Fiddler on the Roof meant to have good looking/detailed sets despite the musical being set in a small Russian village in 1905?" The original Boris Aronson designs are well documented (there are amazing sketches and pictures in Frank Rich's Aronson book), and run the gamut from lush and stage-filling (the interior of Tevye's house, the Tavern for L'Chayim and the entire Wedding sequence) to the mundane and frankly threadbare (the traveler curtains in one for Tevye's back yard or the street scene for "I Just Heard"
.
I first saw the B'way show in 1967 when I was 11, and then a revival with Zero in the late 70's I believe. Those relatively empty stage pictures were filled to the brim with movement and emotion and just enough detail to let your imagination fill in the rest. And most glorious of all was that huge turntable (with a smaller turntable set within it) around which the entire staging was conceived. You kept returning to the circle in scene after scene. Tevye's house spun on it, the Tavern's back wall spun around from Interior to Exterior, and best of all, the villagers said their goodbyes by slowly stepping OFF the turntable one by one as Anatevka ceased to be in the show's final beats. Can you do the show without that turntable as I understand Sher and Yeargan have decided to do? I'll find out this Saturday night...