chernjam said: "CATSNYrevival said: "Should have just filmed the concert for one of the streaming platforms."
As an avid Sunset fan, who 28 years later still listen to the score regularly, I personally want to see a movie just to have another experience of what I think is one of ALW's best scores (and hoping that as a "new number" that perhaps they're going to re-write the finale which has always seemed to be the one thing that was lacking).
That being said, I've kind of lost the enthusiasm I had for this. The length of time for it to come together as a full movie-musical is reminiscent of Cats. As much as Close had this amazing presence even in the revival that helped her to overcome the shortcomings vocally, not sure that's going to translate well on film without a live audience, and not sure even as a story will be a draw as for many (most?) people have little understanding of the history of films let alone the "silent era."
I agree filming the live production in front of a live audience, perhaps with the original Napier sets -in front of a live audience (as they did so well with Love Never Dies) would seem the best bet.
"
I could have written this myself. I, too, listen to the cast recording on a regular basis (Close, Carroll, Lupone, Buckley, Schneider...I have them from the 90s!). But I'm afraid this will end up on Netflix or Amazon if this does go forward with Close, who's now 74. (Streisand should have done it 20 years ago instead of 'Fockers', IMO).
As for the Minnelli / Collins duet, I think Collins sounded and looked better than Minnelli. Maybe Collins can star as Norma Desmond...maybe Linda Evans as Betty Schaffer, and throw in a fight in Norma's Lily Pond and we're all set. (Why not bring back Jeff James as 'Joe Gillis'?).