Long time lurker, first time poster. Saw this on the 1st, I was hugely excited, as Sweeney has been a long time favorite, and I was bananas excited to hear the 26 piece orchestra.
Kind of flummoxed by the number of posts about the sound here— as has been stated before, the sound mixing will inevitably improve through previews, and it *is* unreasonable to expect perfection at early performances. On the other hand, though, I was fortunate enough to catch Parade at NYCC, and that original run had an even shorter on-ramp. Even at the second show there, you could feel that orchestra in your BONES, no matter where in the house you sat.
To my eye, the problems worth quibbling about in this production have less to do with sound and more to do with stakes. For all the talk about a “more human” Sweeney Todd, and trying to show him as a normal man who descends into madness, I have to say that I feel that’s a misguided choice. The show is subtitled “the demon barber of fleet street,” not “the human and relatable barber of fleet street.” As Sondheim has said, it’s a melodrama! I don’t see the intrigue in a naturalistic production. If I’m promised a demon barber, I want a DEMON barber, goddamn it (I kid)! The factory whistle is indeed sorely missed, and without it, the entire thing feels so… literal. Definitely a point of taste, and not something I can speak on objectively, but if a director is going to impose their will on a writer’s work, I’d rather it be a big swing (a la Doyle), than a middle of the road option.
Gotta be honest, the choreography felt a little unintentionally funny to me. I wouldn’t be mad if every single ensemble member in Sweeney had two left feet— just don’t see the appeal of a movement driven production in my eyes.
This is a bizarre observation, but I also felt the musical execution was a little safe. Lac does polish and precision, and where that works, it WORKS. But for Sweeney, I found myself missing the glorious, smeary imprecision from the OBC. To my ear, it felt kinda timid, and I’d have rather been afraid the orchestra was about to rattle apart at any minute than hear something that felt so slick.
just my two cents, I sincerely hope everyone ignores me. Very fortunate to have been able to see this, and hopeful that they can tighten (or loosen?) some things up in previews!
Updated On: 3/3/23 at 01:26 PM