ellingjt said: "I wanted to share our line experience here because I learned a lot from this thread and wanted to give some info back. My wife and I went to the 2pm show on Saturday, 12/17.
We had a very limited time in the city, so we wanted to hire a line sitter. Over a month ago, I PM'd HamiltonObsessed and set it up. I had plane tickets purchased, and was at the airport on Friday, on my way to NYC, when I got a text that he was cancelling because it was supposed to be cold and snow. This put me in quite a bind, so I made a new post asking if anyone else could help me out and luckily lgm20162 PM'd me and we set it up.
I got to the line at about 4am to make sure I would be close to first in line. I ended up being the first and no one else showed up until about 5:30/5:45 when one person showed up. lgm20162 came and subbed out with me at about 6am, and held my place in line until 12:30 when I came back, and then he hung out to see who all got in. He can speak more to how many people showed up and at what time, but it sounds like by about 9:30am there were 10 or so people in line. We didn't end up getting called into the box office until 1:45pm or so (15 min before show time). We got 2 unclaimed lottery tickets, front row! I texted lgm20162 to see who else got in and it sounds like they gave out 10 tickets and 1 standing room only ticket. Show was incredible, Michael Luwoye blew me away and I enjoyed all of the rest of the cast as well.
I highly highly recommend lgm20162 if you want to go the line sitter route. He's done the line a bunch of times and was knowledgeable about the process. He made friends with the people behind me in line and nobody minded at all when we came back to sub back in. Very responsive via text and gave me a lot of updates and was super flexible. Thanks man, I really appreciate it!!
I am disappointed with HamiltonObsessed and can't really recommend him as a line sitter. It seemed like it was going to work out really well, but it left me in a huge bind by cancelling at the last minute. I don't want to badmouth anybody, so I'll just say that if you are looking for a dependable line sitter, send lgm20162 a PM.
"
So I thought I will share my own experience as well. I was also hoping to get cancellation tickets for the 12/17 matinee. I didn't put out a general request because I saw you were also interested in the show and in my convoluted analysis of the situation, I thought making the request would impede my chances. So I privately reached out to HamiltonObsessed and one other member. Since the latter member could get in line earlier, I decided to go with him. I passionately pleaded with an appeal to his honor not to flake on someone who was flying in just the see the show. But lo and behold, he didn't show up in line and didn't even notify me so I didn't realize what was happening until Saturday morning.
I don't have any negative feelings towards this member. I knew this informal line sitting agreement arranged through this forum was risky but I was willing to take on the risk for the steep discount. But I did spend most of Saturday morning cursing to myself about why I didn't go with HamiltonObsessed. Now I know that wouldn't have worked out either. Although it was cold on Friday, the Saturday weather was quite mild albeit rainy.
Everything did work out in the end. I ended up winning the lottery for the Phantom matinee and enjoyed the afternoon there. On Sunday, I originally held tickets to the Color Purple but I received an e-mail mid-morning indicating Jennifer Holliday called out and we could obtain refunds. I saw it as a sign so I quickly took up on the refund and rushed over to the Richard Rodgers Theatre. Although the cancellation line was too long at this point for me to get a realistic shot, I chatted with the people ahead of me and made a judgement call that they weren't willing to pay more than $200. I went on Stubhub and fixated on a seat in Row F center. Thanks to to the advice from the thread, I knew to go to the business center at the Marriott and kept on clicking refresh on that seat. At 2:39pm the price went down to $400 which was what I would have paid for line sitting so I jumped at the purchase. It took another ~12 minutes for the ticket to become downloadable on SH but I was all ready to print and dash out next door.
Unfortunately I cannot say I liked Michael Luwoye and the rest of the cast as much as I did the Chicago cast. However, having the amazing seats helped to compensate somewhat for the disparity in the quality of the two casts. Next time I am in Chicago I will be able to get similarly awesome seats.