I'm getting home from tonight's first preview and overall I liked it, often liked it a lot, but wasn't head over heels in love with it. Maybe I can blame the hype surrounding the show- I mean hearing stuff like this is the best show of our adult lives (and that could be a very short or very long time depending on the person!) certainly didn't help. The best shows for me are things I have a deep, emotional connection with; mix in a little catharsis and you're golden. That was missing for me with Hamilton, and truly the fault lies not with the show, but with those inflating expectations beyond reason and, of course, with myself for getting too caught up in the hype.
I felt like someone who posted earlier about the first two songs: they left me unsure and wondering if I was going to mesh well with the tone of piece. Once the women entered I felt much more at ease, and Renee Elise Goldsberry, brilliant woman that she is, nailed her big number about never being satisfied. (There is no song list in the Playbill, so we'll all have to do our best referring to song titles.) I loved every moment that Goldsberry was on stage and was sad that she disappeared for much of act two.
The other incredible showstopper was given to Leslie Odom Jr, perhaps titled In the Room Where It Happens. It was a huge act two number that had near Fosse-like choreography and was one of the more straight-up showtune style songs. Odom killed it; he's giving the best performance of his career.
Daveed Diggs was my other favorite actor. His Jefferson and Lafayette felt distinctive and both were a lot of fun. He's the scene stealer and his performance has Tony written all over it. It looks like Hamilton is his Broadway debut, so he must be feeling pretty good tonight!
The design is deceptively simple; the turntable was utilized to good effect and was greatly enhanced by the lighting design. The costumes were period, yet sexy.
The lyrics were clever and wonderful, but there are a lot of them and frequently they fly by with lightning speed. I wish act one had ended sooner just so I had a chance to catch my breath and digest some of what I had been hearing. We all know the plot (like 1776), but everything moves a mile a minute so the quieter moments are a nice respite from the frantic pace. I think some tweaks in the sound design will help clear up the occasional lyric issue too.
I just wish I had been able to identify with Hamilton, or any of the characters really. I missed out on a personal connection like I felt with Alison in Fun Home or Bobby in Company or (all too painfully) with Daniel Breaker in Passing Strange. I mean I'm still in therapy over that phone call he had with Eisa Davis! I don't know if I'd go so far as to say that Hamilton left me cold, but I think it's meant to excite in other ways than I was expecting.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!