I saw a regional production of this show in Germany like 2 years ago and loved it. When done right, it can definitely be great. I don't see why it shouldn't be as successful as American in Paris or even Anything Goes. It's funny, charming, has amazing opportunities for dancing and some great acting parts.
That is, of course, when done right.
Dreamcasting Katie Rose Clarke as Lina and Kristen Beth Williams as Kathy, and then somewhat more of a "star" as Don. Aaron Tveit maybe?
Who was in the production in Paris? Anyone that might transfer with it?