I feel very conflicted. So here's my thought: this group was started by a bitter actor who just does not get it. While the Tony Awards are considered as prestigious as the Grammys/Oscars/Emmys, the reason they have such low ratings is because people are less involved. It might be a promotion thing, it may also be due to accessibility to theatre. Movies/television/music will always be out there, while theatre is only accessed on Broadway or on tour, which can be more expensive per person than taking a whole family to the movies. So, how to promote a bunch of theatre snobs, hard-working actors, and the occasional A-Lister? Add a bunch of celebs.
From an artistic standpoint, Paula Abdul, Green Day, and even Will Smith may seem silly, regardless of theatre involvement. But if someone is a star and is remotely involved, they may help with ratings. Another note: Will Smith or Kristin Chenoweth even would be a more "famous" host than Sean Hayes. He is not a ratings darling....
"I saw Pavarotti play Rodolfo on stage and with his girth I thought he was about to eat the whole table at the Cafe Momus." - Dollypop