i was there tonight. fantastic production as all have reported. a naked production that just lets the characters and the lyrics shine.
Julia Lester and Cole Thompson were out; I thought their understudies were fine, especially Alex Joseph Grayson. Everyone was pretty much perfect but Sara Bareilles, just.... I'm a proud defender of Beanie Feldstein's right to be mediocre in a musical, but what her most miserable critics are too hostile to articulate is that she's missing a certain Musical Theater Magic and I think Bareilles might just embody it. Completely hilarious, warm, adorable, all at the same time. Never saw her in Waitress but now I wish I had. Theater award politics make no sense, I know, but she deserves all the awards.
I wasn't as taken with Brian D'Arcy James, whose talent is undeniable and sounds great, but seems... old for this role? I have only ever seen the 2002 revival, so maybe James Corden is seeping into my brain here, but the role seems to scream for an immature, naiive guy to grow into a man. BDJ naturally exudes maturity/responsibility. Just seems like a miscast role. (Even though he does great work with it...)
Lots of mic drops tonight. Whoever is running the sound over there is not on their game. And I could not understand Annie Golden whenever she spoke, in any of her two-three characters.