Saw the show last night. As many of said, an exemplary production. Remarkably cast top to bottom. Brian was back and was superb. Sara was a revelation: I was really worried her tone and lack of higher range (in Sondheim mode) would be an impediment, but the earthiness and humor she brought to the role that was transfixing. I was upset about missing Julia Lester, as a HSMTMTS fan, but Delphi Borich was dazzling. So great to see Creel on stage, and so effortlessly stealing the scene anytime he was on, just brilliant.
Only real notes? I'm a bit mixed on Patina, while I'm a big fan, I wasn't always sure about her vocals, though she was wonderful acting-wise. Also, I kind of felt Rapunzel and her Prince weren't as well-defined as I remember in other productions, but maybe that's just my memory.
My only real issue was the audience. I don't think I've ever seen so loud and enthusiastic crowd! But with that, it started to feel a little American Idol-like, in that in many cases they couldn't wait to start applauding the end of a song, but at the cost of being able to hear the luscious sounds of the Encores! orchestra, or even the end of the performers' notes. There were also a couple of moments in Act 2 where something sad just happened, but the audience would whoop it up because it was the end of a song or someone just exited Stage Left.
(Also, I was in the mezzanine. Why was it so warm?)
That said, I'd love to go back to see Julia, and Cheyenne, and really just to hear that orchestra again. It's just a wonderful few hours at the theatre.
"Hey little girls, look at all the men in shiny shirts and no wives!" - Jackie Hoffman, Xanadu, 19 Feb 2008