#51
Posted: 2/1/08 at 9:23pm
I really respect the opinions given but....
I saw this film at the cinema with my Grandmother in Glasgow when it was released. We both loved it and cried when young Patrick ran into Mame's arms at the end of the MAME title song. This scene is reprised at the end of the film and we cried again. We laughed a lot too through the film but not in any knowing, deriding way but simply because we enjoyed it.
All the great feelings I had when I first saw it at the age of 12 still come back when I see it now. I still have my Gran's PHOTOPLAY from the release of the movie and all the talk is about Lucy's energy and her ability to shoot the dance scenes in "one take" (not sure I believe that one).
My partner watched it on TV with me for the first time not long after we met 14 years ago and he laughed at me when I cried again. He loves the movie now. Isn't the title music great?
I love the film. I know it is very flawed as I go to the theatre all the time and know Lucy was miscast but I still think she looks beautiful and her costumes were stunning and her house was amazing etc. etc. I finde her touching and sincere. I just can't bring myself to apply the later knowledge I have gained about performances to something I saw when I was young and I genuinely still get great pleasure from this movie. I think it is worth finding your own opinion and taking time to watch this movie.
I watch the VHS very ocassionally but REALLY wish I had a widescreen version of the film (does anyone know if it is available?). I would have (probably) preferred Angela but didn't know that when I first saw the film at the cinema so I still really enjoy Lucy.
Better start rewinding the tape......
The short answer is ... I don't think it is "THAT" bad.
I saw this film at the cinema with my Grandmother in Glasgow when it was released. We both loved it and cried when young Patrick ran into Mame's arms at the end of the MAME title song. This scene is reprised at the end of the film and we cried again. We laughed a lot too through the film but not in any knowing, deriding way but simply because we enjoyed it.
All the great feelings I had when I first saw it at the age of 12 still come back when I see it now. I still have my Gran's PHOTOPLAY from the release of the movie and all the talk is about Lucy's energy and her ability to shoot the dance scenes in "one take" (not sure I believe that one).
My partner watched it on TV with me for the first time not long after we met 14 years ago and he laughed at me when I cried again. He loves the movie now. Isn't the title music great?
I love the film. I know it is very flawed as I go to the theatre all the time and know Lucy was miscast but I still think she looks beautiful and her costumes were stunning and her house was amazing etc. etc. I finde her touching and sincere. I just can't bring myself to apply the later knowledge I have gained about performances to something I saw when I was young and I genuinely still get great pleasure from this movie. I think it is worth finding your own opinion and taking time to watch this movie.
I watch the VHS very ocassionally but REALLY wish I had a widescreen version of the film (does anyone know if it is available?). I would have (probably) preferred Angela but didn't know that when I first saw the film at the cinema so I still really enjoy Lucy.
Better start rewinding the tape......
The short answer is ... I don't think it is "THAT" bad.
"Your eyes..... they shine like the pants on my blue serge suit"